I have issues.
As I look back on this rather disheartening episode of Ousama Ranking, I can say this – it wasn’t a surprise. Or at least it shouldn’t have been, because it was basically the logical consequence of the troubling threads that have been running through the entire second cour. In practice of course this does feel rather a jolt, because it comes on the heels of possibly the series’ best (and most visually stunning) episode. This was a pain deferred, not denied – it’s been pretty clear for a while where Ousama Ranking was going.
Ultimately it comes down to perspective. And mine is that neither Miranjo or Bosse deserve a free pass for their crimes. Bosse’s whole raison d’être is lost on me – “I want to be the strongest in the world”. It’s almost a bit of sly shounen self-parody – except it doesn’t seem to be that at all. It’s one thing for Bosse to have that desire – if he’d gone about it the right way, you could chalk it up to too much martial spirit. But he seems to think it’s perfectly fine to kill anyone he cares to test himself against, as long as they’re strong. Both the end and the means are kind of dumb as far as I’m concerned.
Compounding the wrongness is Miranjo’s involvement. She doubles down on the evils of Bosse’s dream by committing a series of even more vile crimes to make it come true. It starts with the betrayal of the demon (who has his own sad backstory, naturally) and just keeps building from there. The premise seems to be that because Miranjo had a painful childhood she isn’t to blame for any of her sins – I disagree. Forgiving her doesn’t bring Bojji’s mother back, or Dorsche’s foot or eye, or make up for the painful childhood Bojji has had to endure because of her. I mean, at least Miranjo has the excuse of bad fortune – Bosse doesn’t even have that – but she’s even more culpable than he is.
The cherry on top is Daida swooping in and foiling Despa’s plan to save Ouken. One could take issue with whether the demon would even be that bothered about his head – he surely could have taken it back on his own, though I suppose if your existence is to gain power by granting wishes you wouldn’t try so hard to dodge that eventuality. Despa and Ouken really are pretty blameless in the larger picture – Ouken has certainly done some terrible things but in my view that’s not even really Ouken – he’s effectively possessed. But they get shafted in favor of Miranjo, which as a scenario can kiss my ass.
In the final analysis this is the biggest problem: because the genuinely nice people (Bojji, Kage, Despa, et al) are so willing to be forgiving (because that’s how nice people are), the douchebags are allowed to be douchebags without suffering any real consequences for it. And Daida proposing to Miranjo? Yeah, try next door because I’m not buying that. Never mind that he’s like 10 years old or whatever – he’s been through hell because of Bosse and Miranjo. And even if that doesn’t bother him, he’s pre-empting justice for all the other people wronged by them.
The best part of all this was Hillng’s reaction, because she was the only person who seemed to see sense. Hilling continues to be a great character – I mean, you gotta love a tsundere mom, for starters. But her love for her boys is so genuine she can’t help herself. She’s a character with some balance to her – she’s a good soul but given to anger and impulsiveness. Desha is another one who’s interestingly nuanced – in the final analysis, I think, much kinder than he wants to be seen as. Having had their plan to rescue their brother foiled, Desha agrees to accept the #1 ranking – which means going to the treasure house and accepting whatever it was that made those other kings insane. The jester calls is a selfish act but to me it’s pretty selfless – Desha knows the likely cost of what he’s doing.
Given how strong Desha is the mad king version is a rather scary thought (that’s for Part II, I guess). And there’s one other troubling matter here – is Daida going to stand down and let Bojji have the throne? Bojji is the rightful king both by succession and decree, and by dint of strength besides. But again, he’s so much nicer than Daida that he might be willing to step aside and let the douchier brother be rewarded for being douchier. That would suck – though seeing the costs associated with being a king in this mythology, sweet and kind Bojji is probably better off.
Theleux
March 19, 2022 at 12:00 amCan’t really say I agree here with a lot of the conflicting points, but again; like you mentioned, it comes down to perspective. Ousama Ranking has always been a fairly idealistic but morally focused series, and one of the biggest struggles characters have had to deal with throughout the entire narrative is offering forgiveness. It takes a hell of a lot of will to forgive someone who has hurt you in your past (we witness this too with Bojji when he meets Domas again, that was the first sign of the show heading in this direction.)
Starting with Bosse, who has been the most conflicted individual throughout the entire story up to this point – he indeed was a very straight forward person, selfishly carrying out his desire to be the strongest being in the world. But once he encounters Miranjo’s family and the struggles they experience, his eyes open and he beginnings to change his perspective – he has a better grasp of what he wants most from life (that being living through it and supporting Miranjo). These foreign feelings confuse him at first, but he evidently comes to terms with his actions (which we witness when he is dying in his bed and talking about Daida). Of the whole cast, I think Bosse is the one who most deserves some sort of suffering – he was able to acknowledge his faults but beyond being forced into existence again, he has not faced many struggles. I guess him learning his actual place and how much he has messed up on with his life is big enough, but of the entire cast I do think he is the one who deserved a bit more.
Miranjo on the other hand, had an incredibly unfortunate life and ended up becoming obsessed with her only remaining support. She also made some very significant and selfish choices (such as with making a wish with the demon which I am sure we will learn more about in the future), leading to order attacks on Bosse’s family members to carry out his original desire. However I do not think the show is saying that she doesn’t deserve to be blamed for her sins – she very clearly begins to question her actions as this goes along, and again, one of the biggest notes is her understanding of her faults and her regret over them. Miranjo to me comes off as someone who really lost their way when growing up – she doesn’t really come off like any of the other adult characters in the cast. I don’t view her ‘dying’ at the ending being a suitable punishment, but rather atoning for her sins through living life being aware of them, and educating others to avoid following the same path, is much more fruitful.
Finally, Daida is an interesting case. He has been a rather difficult and selfish individual through the start of the story, only once he is lead into the ‘shadow realm’ does he really begin to understand his poor actions. As Bosse mentions, they are quite similar in how they search for their desires. Daida’s actions are especially conflicting due to how young he is (which to me helps explain a lot of the develops that occur.) One point I want to bring up is that Daida has always known and felt feelings towards Miranjo – initially not knowing that she was the woman in the mirror, but once he does realize, many things come to light for him. I do view many of his decisions (such as the marriage proposal) quite sudden and poorly thought through on his part, but his honesty and desire to spin the situation into one where the both of them at fault can recompense for their actions is quite respectable in my opinion. He still exhibits his strong selfish tendency, similar to his father, but he has found new purpose through it. The next goal now is to showcase these positive developments (which of course take time, unlike simply being sent away/ dying.) As for Ouken, I don’t think having Despa wish for his immortality to be gone will end in anything good in that present situation… he is ground up into a ball and shoved inside a boulder after all. Being immortal means they have plenty of time to find alternative ways of freeing him, without utilizing the questionable demon further.
I wasn’t expecting as much of a conflict from some people (I had read ahead a while back) regarding this development, but I do think it comes down to some personal biases and general perspective of each viewer regarding whether these actions were “enough” to satisfy their own feelings regarding atonement and retribution. It is evident that the idealism the show oozes feels a bit too much for many, for myself I think it is incredibly heartfelt, careful, and understanding in how it is presented. I wouldn’t say it is an issue with the narrative (my biggest complaint has to be with how the Gyakuza “cartoonishly evil” element was handled, but that was the one big writing mishap I’ve felt the story has had), but everyone has their own interpretations of these things.
That being said. We are now pretty well done with the conflict in the home kingdom, so it seems the exploration phase (similar to the first cour) regarding the Ranking of Kings is back in play!
Marty
March 19, 2022 at 6:27 amHere’s some food for thought: How paramount is the ending to the overall Part?
I can honestly say this is the worst episode of the series thus far, not because of any technical shortcomings but because of the narrative and Thematic implications.
The fact remains that as much as I agree with your post, I think the most egregious part of the episode to me is the fact that it is narratively essential to the plot; had they not been foiled, Desha wouldn’t have needed to go to the treasure vault. If he indeed becomes the big bad of Part II, that means that Miranjo’s “redemption” is essential for the plot to develop. I can’t say that establishes a solid foundation for Part II.
Also, it seems like Despa was a little too quick to forgive being robbed from saving his brother.
Guardian Enzo
March 19, 2022 at 8:48 amI agree with most of that. Despa being too quick to forgive is part of what I would say is a larger issue, to wit nice people letting bad people get away with murder (sometimes literally).
Jo
March 19, 2022 at 10:58 amThis episode gave me whiplash. Kind of disappointed, considering everything that Bojji went through, only for Daida to wake up and go ‘hey! you’re forgiven, be my wife’ to Miranjo as if nothing happen.
Bounty
March 19, 2022 at 7:48 pmI stopped commenting here because frankly, the show has been a constant downhill since the “second cour” started, with episodes 19 (part of it, at least),20, and 21 as notable exceptions.
The problems are quite easy to identify once you read the mangaka’s interview where he said that no one will either die or pay for his crimes because he wants a good ending for everyone involved. Once I read that stuff I understood that Ousama Ranking was a rather stunningly animated story with an interesting incipit, but the mangaka had no idea how to continue that into a cohesive story and decided to go for some kind of fairy tale where everyone is eventually forgiven. The problem is that even in fairy tails, the bads are bad and the goods stay good.
You can’t save everyone, and this appalling ending was kind of foretold. Genuinely disgusted by the character’s writing, but alas, it is what it is.
I guess this was still way better than my expectations, but meh, I thought this could have been a masterpiece. Unfortunately, it won’t. And I’m hardly interested in reading the rest of the manga.
nixx
March 21, 2022 at 5:49 amOh, that world has its own logic with all these killings, healing, and reasoning, which is unfathomable to me. So now I watch it mainly for plot twists. Perhaps the first 13 episodes were the most coherent (best?) part of the show. Hiling is just tremendous. Not gonna lie, I also have a soft spot for Miranjo.
blargnobia
March 22, 2022 at 2:15 pm“She was the coolest guy.”
The only way to salvage this is if next episode is just Hiling screaming at Daida for 23 minutes and then sending him to his room.
Guardian Enzo
March 22, 2022 at 4:19 pmI’d pay to see that.