Seihantai na Kimi to Boku (You and I Are Polar Opposites) – 09

The level of consistency with Seihantai na Kimi to Boku is quite stellar – every ep is  a winner. In a sense it may not be that surprising, though, because this series is extremely straightforward about what it is and does. Simple, even, in some ways. That’s not remotely a criticism – rather, Seihantai never wavers from its mission statement. It knows exactly what wants to do, never tries to do too much, and executes just about perfectly. It’s one of those series that makes excellence look a lot easier than it actually is.

I see the characters fitting that profile very neatly. Miyu is not only incapable of deceit (seemingly), but incapable of an unexpressed thought. She and Yuusuke are polar opposites in some ways, but not in one important one – they’re both honest. They say what they think – he’s just a lot more reticent to do so. I love them individually and collectively but their natures do give their romance just a bit of a one-note quality. As such there can be times  where, when their segments go on for a long time, I find myself wishing (just a little) that we’d look in on the supporting cast.

It’s almost unfair to compare, honestly, but Taira is really the star of the show for me at this point. He has it easy – he’s not the protagonist. He’s not part of the main pairing. In romcoms especially it’s not hard for characters like Taira to steal the show. But in Polar Opposites Taira is really the one to bring a very different vibe to the table. He’s constantly puzzled by life, and we get a running commentary from his inner voice. If you notice, we get very little internal monologue from any of the other supporting cast. Even Miyu, because the fact that she always says whatever’s in her head makes it redundant. Apart from Tani no other character gives their perspective on things as much as Taira-kun.

The whole birthday thing worked because of Taira, IMHO. Tani-kun looking up “reactions that make people happy” was hilariously in-character. But what I really loved was that he went to Taira for advice – because Taira is to reactions what Miyu is to thoughts. Everything he feels he expresses on his face – I hope he never tries to play poker (or even Old Maid). And the thing is, birthdays are tough for guys like Shuuji and Yuusuke (I hear). Being fussed over – or Goc forbid sung to – is truly mortifying. But you they do want someone to notice. Like, I might add, Azuma-san did in middle school (and he still has the Yeti seal she gave him).

Yuusuke’s birthday is three weeks after Shuuji’s. So when Miyu takes him to Popuri to buy mini-cakes, they each buy a candy for Taira (having heard from Azuma) and Suzuki-san gently scolds him for not sharing. This was a lovely little moment – underplayed but just right and the sort of kindness that makes a huge difference in someone’s day. There’s also a great bit where Tani-kun grinds over whether to stay up til midnight, correctly guessing Miyu might call him. He fails but she does call (Tem-purr-a gets woken up too) and he badly pretends like he was still up. It ends with an “Aishiteru” she assumes he won’t hear, and a mumbled reciprocation. I don’t know if he’ll remember but she sure will.

Finally, Miyu suggests Yuusuke pick a date spot for a celebratory outing. He wonders is he’s too passive (yes, you are), and finally chooses the natural history museum – partly because he remembers he liked it in elementary school, but mostly because it should suck up enough time. The special exhibition (I’m guessing some kind of pop culture crossover based on the crowd) is a disaster but the main exhibits are (as usual) mostly deserted. Likewise Tani’s restaurant choice (closed), but with these two it kind of always works out in the end.

That’s the allure of this romance but also a bit of a limiter, in truth. The cuteness is legit and charming as hell (I mean, that look-around by Yuusuke before the hug), but there’s never too much doubt that things will be just fine. It does make me long for a bit more time with the other couples, especially TairAzuma. It’s testament to how winning a couple they are that I never wish for strife between MiYuusuke to liven things up – they’re fine as they are. But sometimes I just want a little more or the other ingredients mixed in to balance things out.

Facebooktwitterlinkedininstagramflickrfoursquaremail

2 comments

  1. r

    It may not have been the big surprise she originally had planned, but I’m pretty sure her task of making Tani-kun never going back to regular birthdays was achieved pretty sucessfully. The cake scene was adorable, and the post-birthday date certainly ended on something he won’t forget.

  2. N

    So Yettis were back when cast was in middle school, but the movie just recently came out. Either it’s a franchise or that’s a continuity.

    I have been feeling a lack of Yamada and Library Girl these last two episodes. I like the main couple well enough, but yeah, they’re quite predictable.

Leave a Comment