Rurouni Kenshin: Meiji Kenkaku Romantan (2023) – 16

Damn five minute episodes…

I knew the Raijuuta arc was better than its reputation.  That, unfortunately, is based mostly on the 1996 anime’s treatment of it – which left a lot to be desired.  That reflected director Furuhashi Kazuhiro’s reported disinterest in the arc, perhaps due to its reliance on the “decline of kenjutsu” theme Furuhashi played down generally speaking.  It also probably doesn’t help that its sandwiched roughly in-between the two flashiest arcs of the Tokyo saga, featuring its two most-beloved guest characters.

Even I’ve been a bit surprised by just how good these last two episodes have been, though.  And this one really flew by – there wasn’t so much as a wasted moment here.  The focus here is actually more on Yutaro, Raijuuta’s apprentice (in name only).  Raijuuta declaration of Kenshin as an enemy closed out last week’s episode, and he wastes no time in acting on it.  This duel is a one-way street – Raijuuta relentlessly attacks, and Ken dodges seemingly without too much trouble.  Just as Raijuuta is mocking him for running away, Kenshin takes a battoujutsu stance and shows the attacker in no uncertain terms what God-like speed is all about (and how he got his nickname).

That settles things for the moment, though clearly only for the moment.  Yahiko and Yutaro pick up where they left off, and Yahiko challenges the lad to stop following Raijuuta around like a dog and come to challenge him on his own.  Which he does, in the middle of the night.  But it soon becomes clear that any notion of Raijuuta “training” the boy is a farce – Yutaro doesn’t even know how to grip a shinai properly.  Kaoru having a natural sympathy for lost little boys (and a desperate need for students) offers to give Yutaro some training, and he and Yahiko have a chance to continue their developing rivalry.

That in itself is an interesting topic.  There was some talk that Watsuki intended to make Yutaro into a full-on rival for Yahiko, in true battle shounen fashion.  I won’t spoil for those of you who don’t know the series even now, but circumstances took things in some different directions, and we’ll never know for sure.   What’s clear is that there are many parallels between the two boys’ stories.  Like Yahiko Yutaro is a the son of a samurai and fiercely proud of it.  But rather than destitute, Yutaro’s father became rich by abandoning the samurai life and becoming a sword merchant (specializing in the overseas trade).  His shame over that is what’s driving Yutaro to learn swordsmanship – as Kenshin notes, so similar to Yahiko and yet so different.

What’s also clear is that the whole “bandit attack” which delivered Yutaro and his father into Raijuuta’s hands is as much of a lie as calling himself Yutaro’s master.  Raijuuta is a very principled man, in a way – it’s only one principle but he does believe the hell out of it.  The problem is no other principles will stand in his way in trying to achieve his goal.  That would including ambushing Kenshin as he walks the estate with the others – hardly an honorable way for one swordsman to challenge another.

Kenshin dealt with Raijuuta with seeming ease the first time they clashed, but the latter was holding back his ultimate attack – Tobi-Izuna, a slashing technique which relies on creating a vacuum and sending it flying outward like a blade.  Kenshin is surprised enough by this to have to dodge it – but in doing so, he allows it to cut Yutaro.  The truth is out there now and Kenshin is already pissed, but when Raijuuta shows no concern whatsoever for having injured his own student, he’s clearly had enough.  He promises Raijuuta a true duel once he’s taken Yutaro for treatment, and it’s clear from his demeanor that he means business.

Awakening this sleeping tiger is a pretty terrible idea, but Raijuuta has no idea what he’s let himself in for.  Unfortunately for Yutaro, though his life is not in danger the attack has severed the nerves and tendons in his right arm, rendering it useless for swordsmanship.  That may not mean anything to Raijuuta, but for Kenshin it’s a betrayal of everything a swordsman and master of a style should stand for.  All the more proof, then, that it swordsmanship’s only path forward to the one Raijuuta aspires to, it’s not worth saving.

Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedinmail

7 comments

  1. W

    Bear in mind, the manga version of the arc was not perfect either (we just need to have a look at Watsuki’s comments on his dissapointment at how Raijuta turned out in the end). That said, I’m delighted at the way it’s getting adapted here, clearly the producers understood its flaws and made the necessary slight changes to improve it and, above it all, put the themes into a better light.

  2. J

    Elephant in the room aside, it feels like the only purpose this adaptation serves to do is to be a more “faithful” adaptation of the manga so that it adapts the final arc in the manga that fans sorely were denied thanks to all of that horrible filler that got the show cancelled. But really, to what end? What does adapting this particular arc “better” do that the 1996 version cannot? Just to satisfy the fans who wanted a less “butchered” adaptation? It’s so egregious especially after I saw what amounted to one of the most redundant remakes in a sea of redundant “faithful” anime remakes last season with the first arc but done much worse and much shoddier looking compared to the 1996 version.

  3. Would have you have said the same about Hunter X Hunter 2011?

  4. J

    The thing is, is that the 2011 HxH had the dignity to put its own directorial touches to material that Furuhashi had already treaded back in 1999 (although the fact that the filler was significantly better than Kenshin’s numerous filler arcs didn’t hurt it either). It was familiar yes, but it still approached it in a way that felt fresh to new viewers and veterans alike. And also that HxH 2011 just covers significantly more material than the 1999 series did (unless you also count the OVAs too), compared to how Kenshin was cancelled right before the final arc was covered.

    On the other hand, there’s nothing about Kenshin 2023 that Furuhashi did better back in 1996 outside of the aforementioned filler arcs. It even looks worse arguably despite the advancements in tech and nothing I saw from the Tokyo arc gave me any hope that Kyoto will be any better. All it has left is nothing but nostalgia behind it especially when the inevitable sakuga orgy arrives come Kyoto. I dread the part when the Remembrance Arc is inevitably covered.

    tl;dr HxH 2011 was far more inspired as an adaptation redo than Kenshin 2023.

  5. K

    Personally, I think the Jinchuu arc never being properly adapted is reason enough to give RK another series, though I do wonder how this series is going to go through the Kyoto arc. I was just watching the climax of the final battle from the arc and it’s hard to imagine that level of music, animation, and style being approached again, let alone eclipsed.

  6. J

    To be fair, there *was* a perfectly fine OVA adaptation of the backstory portion of the Jinchuu arc back in 1999. And that one had a level of craft and ambition to transcend its manga origins (rather than elevating it) that I doubt this reboot will ever achieve when it inevitably gets there. Granted, the actual OVA that tried to adapt the main Jinchuu arc plot was a big letdown, but I digress.

  7. Both OVAs were fanfic at best. it’s just that one was competent and the other a complete travesty. Neither have any bearing on there never having been a proper adaptation of Jinchu in anime form.

Leave a Comment