Spring 2022 Preview and Video Companion

In many years spring is anime’s main course, but in 2022 it looks like the appetizer.

I don’t know what kind of season Spring 2022 will turn out to be – we never know for sure until it happens.  It certainly looks a step up from winter (as is normal).  But my instinctive reaction when I started putting this preview together was that when one considers how many big series announcements we’ve seen, Spring 2022 looks fairly tame.  There are some prospects to be sure, but few of the headliners are here (only one huge name for me).  And none of the truly massive sequels already announced – those will all come later in the year (or, as I increasingly suspect will be the case with at least a couple, 2023).

As occurs with almost unerring regularity, I’m previewing about a third of the full schedule this spring (16 series out of 49, if one includes Netflix).  I’m amazed that this seems to happen season after season but indeed it does.  Something like 50 shows isn’t huge for spring by modern standards, though it clearly still exceeds the industry’s production capacity (as witness the black company working conditions which have become the norm).

There’s no question in my mind that the big dog is Spy X Family (the “X” is silent, like after/before “Hunter”).  It’s one of my two candidates for the next monster hit, has a big-name director and studio, and a source material that’s both widely acclaimed and a huge seller.  There are sequels on the board that are sure to be commercial powerhouses (Kaguya and Komi in the same season, for example) though none of those are of much interest to me.  Indeed, in my sphere it’s an extraordinarily light season for sequels, with only Kingdom and the Netflix-dumped Tiger & Bunny likely to be shows I follow.

The mix looks pretty 2020’s normally to me, overall.  Something like a dozen LN adaptations and half that many originals and game adaptations.  No genres jump out as spiking – a couple of sports shows, maybe slightly less CGTCT than in some seasons.  If anything the overall block appears slightly slanted towards comedies and “lighter” material as opposed to action and serious drama.  Is that a positive?  Well, I adore anime comedy when done well so in theory, sure.  But the batting average for comedies, romantic and otherwise, has not been great these last few years.  Here’s hoping…

As always the LiA preview comes with a video companion (also embedded at the end of this post).  If you enjoy that or any of my videos I would be enormously grateful if you’d consider subscribing – helping me reach that magic 1000 number is a great way of helping out LiA reach sustainability. I look forward to your feedback as I fine-tune the video productions – please share your thoughts either here or over on YT. And as always, my sincere thanks for your support.

 

Let’s move on to the preview.  As usual, the poll is in the sidebar – please go vote!

 

Highest Expectations:

Spy X Family – Wit/CloverWorks: (PV) Setting aside my personal anticipation level (and it’s not far off there, either) this adaptation of Endo Tatsuya’s manga is the clear headliner this season.   It’s one of my two candidates to be the next commercial monster (in the footsteps of Jujutsu Kaisen and Tokyo Revengers), for a number of reasons.  It seems to be something of a perfect storm – a manga that’s both massively popular and critically loved, Wit co-producing, a big name director, a tremendous amount of buzz.  Most of the betting is on Chainsaw Man, but I wouldn’t be shocked if it’s this series that tops the commercial rankings for franchises that have 2022 anime premieres.

S x F is one of those series (you can add Frieren and Witch Hat now) that have been on my reading list forever, but put on hold when the anime was announced.  I’ve scanned it a bit, I like what I see, and it’s hard to find a reader who says anything bad about it.  I have no idea if it’s truly great, but it certainly has the “it” factor in the water cooler department.  The story of the titular spy family (featuring an esper stepdaughter), it seems to have the right combination of wit, grit, and sheer creative ambition to cross over into the mainstream.  And in Anya (the daughter) it has a secret weapon that’s given it big appeal with younger kids and female readers.  With Wit co-producing (with CloverWorks), Furuhashi Kazuhiro directing, and two (split) cours to start with, all the pieces seem to be in place for a major, major splash.

Spy X Family isn’t a perfect candidate to be a colossal hit – but then neither is Chainsaw Man (it may be a bit too gruesomely dark), and I certainly wouldn’t have pegged JJK or TR to be as big as they’ve become.  S x F isn’t a WSJ series, which makes it harder to join that most exclusive club (though TR overcome that).  And it may be just a bit too quirky and “highbrow” to bridge demographics like those ultra-elite commercial cyclones have.  If I were betting I’d put money on it being “merely” a very big hit (think Boku no Hero Academia or Haikyuu!!) as opposed to otherworldly.  But it wouldn’t shock me to see it storm the barricades and stand alongside Tokyo Revengers at least, though JJK seems like a bit too much of an ask.

Ao Ashi – Production I.G.: (PV) It’s been way too long since we’ve  had a really good soccer anime (Ginga e Kickoff, I guess).  Plenty of mediocre or even decent ones,  mind, but given how many terrific soccer manga are out there, anime hasn’t been kind to the genre in recent years.  Hopefully that will change with Ao Ashi, a very good manga indeed if not a masterpiece.  This is certainly my top pick among this seasons dollop of sports series.

In my mind’s eye there’s kind of a big three of “blue” soccer manga along a continuum from most traditional to most “modern”.  Be Blues is at the traditional end and Blue Lock (also getting a 2022 adaptation) at the other, with Ao Ashi in the middle.  For my tastes it’s also in the middle in terms of quality – I really love Be Blues (it’s basically the Majorof soccer), but Ao Ashi is a very winning series (nominated for the Manga Taisho in 2017 and winner of the Shogokukan “General Manga” award in 2020) with a likable titular protagonist.  He’s a middle schooler from the inaka with big dreams, which are seemingly dashed after he causes the downfall of his team in a big tournament.  But if that were the case, we wouldn’t have a story…

Production I.G. being the studio doesn’t seem to hold as much weight as it once did, but you’d certainly take it over most options.  There’s not a big-name director or heavyweight staff attached to Ao Ashi but I.G. sort of gives you a baseline beneath which you know you won’t drop.  As for series length that’s still unknown, but this is airing on NHK and they almost never do one-cour productions, much less of sports manga.  I’d guess two cours for now, and then we’ll see – the manga is very popular if not on the level of something like Haikyuu.

Kingdom 4th Season – Studio Signpost: (PV) At this point I think you pretty much know what you’re going to get with Kingdom, and what you’re going to get is very good indeed.  The production nightmares seem behind us (Signpost is an offshoot of Pierrot, but things haven’t been distractingly horrible for a good while anyway).  Of course some arcs are going to be better than others with a manga this long, but in the anime at least the writing has always maintained a pretty high standard.  Hara Yasuhisa has been at this for over 15 years now, and Kingdom has become one of the most popular manga in the world for a reason.

For my tastes Season 3 was probably the best of the series so far.  There are individual sections in the first two that match it (though dismal visuals were a looming danger), but S3 was pretty consistently epic from start to finish.  It obviously adapted a very major arc, so the story by nature has to chart a new direction from here.  I haven’t read enough of the source material to know what’s coming but I trust Hara at this stage – I expect this season to deliver an appealing mix of grand spectacle and personal drama just as the series always seems to.

 

Mid-table:

Summertime Render – OLM: (PV) There are plenty of reasons to be intrigued by Summertime Render – interesting premise, wonderful PV, two cours for a finished manga.  But the headline is certainly Watanabe Ayumu.  Anytime one of the deans of anime direction both TV and theatrical is attached, you pay attention.  There are limits to what a director can do with adapted material – Watanabe’s flair wasn’t enough to mask Komi Can’t Communicate’s ginormous flaws, for example. But he’s one of the best, and when he’s at the helm of a quirky property like this, it’s of considerable interest to me.

Summertime Render is the story of a young man who as an orphaned child lived with two sisters, one of whom drowned under mysterious (to him) circumstances.  There are apparently some supernatural elements to this but it seems to be mainly a mystery and character drama.  The source manga is quite well-regarded if not unreservedly beloved, for what that’s worth.  13 volumes for 25 episodes sounds about doable, and my hope is that Watanabe agreed to direct because he finds the material to be sufficiently interesting. Largely an unknown for me, but certainly one of the more compelling prospects this season.

Kotarou wa Hitorigurashi – Lidenfilms: (PV) Netflix anime present unique challenges to blogging, and Kotarou is a prime example.  At least it was distributed worldwide rather than making subscribers outside Japan wait a season, as they sometimes do, but how to cover (or even preview) it is a puzzle.  By now many will have seen all of it – I’ve seen some (and can confirm, it’s great).  I don’t even know whether to call it a winter or spring series.  But I do know it’s superb anime, and in the hope that this might convince a few people to check it out, I’m including it in the spring preview.

Kotarou is a manga with quite an interesting history.  The manga itself is an award winner, and the live-action adaptation has been one of the most well-received TV dramas in recent years.  It’s little-known outside Japan but quite a prestige property here.  Manga and anime’s fascination with children living alone seems to reach the point of absurdity here, where the child in question is 4 years old.  I’m withholding judgment on that premise (update: it’s great) until I see how it’s rationalized, but there is obvious potential for emotional resonance in the story.  Director Makino Tomoe did good work on Kitsutsuki Tanteidokoro (though he’s actually directing two series this season, which can be worrisome).  An odd duck, certainly, but Kotarou wa Hitorigurashi has a lot to recommend it, not least that it’s a seinen and that always improves the odds of a series being good.

Kawaii Dake ja Nai Shikimori-san – Doga Kobo: (PV) I always go into romcoms with high hopes – it’s one of my absolute favorite genres.  Most of them aren’t that great and very few are really special, but when you get that rare exception the ceiling is basically unlimited.  I have no reason to expect Kawaii Dake ja Nai Shikimori-san is going to be one of these rare gems, but the overall view of the manga is positive and I tend to like Doga Kobo’s sensibility.

That title translates to “Shikimori Isn’t Just a Cutie” and that seems to sum up the premise pretty accurately.  Stories about herbivore boyfriends with aggressive girlfriends are minefields to be sure, but I don’t get the vibe that this one is especially mean-spirited.  In addition to a studio Shikimori-san shares a director and writer with Senpai ga Uzai Kouhai no Hanashi, and I think it’s fair to say that’s about where my expectation level is – a  breezy, fun weekly escape with people that are weird but easy to like.  If I enjoy this show as much as I did that one, I’ll consider this adaptation a success.

Tiger & Bunny 2 – Bandai Namco Pictures: (PV) Another Netflix production.  Tiger & Bunny 2 is one of the very few sequels I’ll be checking in on this spring.  It seems as if this has come about 7 years too late – at its peak this series was massively popular (especially on Friday at Comiket) but does anyone really still care?  As for myself my expectations are relatively modest – I liked the first season but the last third rather lost the plot as far as I’m concerned.

Still – any chance to hear the great Hirata Hiroaki in a lead role is to be savored these days, and Kotetsu is a great character.  Original writer Nishida Masafumi is back on board, and despite the lackluster final arc there’s certainly nothing in the premise that precludes a sequel (quite the opposite, in fact).  Apropos of nothing, it always depresses me to see “Bandai Namco Pictures” on the masthead – they’ll always be Sunrise to me, even if corporate weasels decide to kill the name.

Dance Dance Danseur – MAPPA: (PV) As far as I know this is the first anime about male ballet dancers, and it’s based on a series by the legendary shoujo mangaka Asakura George.  The story here follows a teenager who was into ballet as a kid but gave it up due to peer pressure, and pursued martial arts.  A female classmate in high school pulls him back into the world of ballet, and romance (I assume) follows.

I know nothing about Asakura’s manga, really, but I do know she has a reputation as a quirky and even weird writer who sometimes dabbles in fantasy.  Sakai Munehisa is certainly an interesting choice as director, since his best-known work has been on One Piece.  This one is distinctive enough to capture my interest, though I’m not going to be shocked if the anime turns out to be kind of a dumpster fire.

 

 

Modestly Interested:

Tomodachi Game – Okuruto Noboru: As usual this is the biggest section of the preview (half).  And the shows in this category are all pretty much of a muchness for me – I could list them in any order without stretching much.  Tomodachi Game probably has the most buzz and the most well-regarded source material, but the premise sounds kind of dumb if I’m honest.  It finds a bunch of high schoolers thrown together by a malicious children’t TV character and forced to play the titular “friendship game” to test their bonds of trust.  Hey, there must be some reason so many people rate the manga highly, right?  That buys it an episode or two to convince me.

Love All Play – Nippon Animation/OLM: (PV) The rest of spring’s sports anime are a big step below Ao Ashi for me, but hope springs (pun intended) eternal.  This marks the second season in a row with a badminton show after a run of- well, forever as far as I know without one. It’s all preamble to Blue Box for me, but that’s 18-24 months off yet.  This one sounds like a pretty standard setup – kid goes to a strong badminton school and tries to make the cut in the demanding environment with the help of his onee-chan and friends.  Original sports anime are rarely really special (this season’s badminton show Ryman’s Club probably represents a high-water mark).

Birdie Wing: Golf Girls’ Story – Bandai Namco Pictures: (PV) Another sports original, so much of the above applies here as well.  The novelty here is that we haven’t see a golf anime in decades.  The sports is phenomenally popular in Japan, but not with the usual anime-viewing (and buying) demographic.  If we’re honest most sports series about female athletes struggle to rise above the “cute girls doing sports cutely” level, but the two heroines seem to be adults at least.  The PVs make it seem as if the silly factor is pretty high with Birdie Wing, but the staff is very experienced and kind of okay, so who knows.

Gunjou no Fanfare – Ley-duce: (PV) Last of the trio, this time we have a sports original about – jockeys?  Okay, that’s a first as far as I know – we’re getting more diversity of sports, if nothing else.  Three 15 year-old boys at a “prestigious horse racing academy” is the premise here, to which I say “why the hell not?”  Let it be known that the ridiculously overexposed Hanae Natsuki is playing the lead both here and in Love All Play (and Summertime Render for that matter), so expect a hearty dose of sameyness.

Aharen-san wa Hakarenai – Felix Film: (PV) A comedy with an odd premise that normally wouldn’t interest me all that much to be honest – a tiny girl with personal space issues and a large guy with an overactive imagination become friends of a sort.  But the staff is good – co-directors Makino (from Kotarou wa Hitorigurashi) and Yamamoto Yasutaka both have a pretty decent track record.  And as best I can tell the manga is pretty well-reviewed.

Kakkou no Iinazuke – SynergySP/Shin-EI: (PV) Another romcom, an adaptation of a shounen manga that’s been running for less than two years.  The plot is seriously improbable – a kid switched at birth is sucked into a scheme by his birth parents to marry the girl they raised.  There’s no real reason to think this will be a high-level performer but, well-  it’s a romcom, it’s not a LN adaptation, and Karakai Jouzu no Takagi-san director Akagi Hiroaki is in charge. There’s enough there to at least make it worth a stab in the dark.

Deaimon – Encourage Films: (PV) Deaimon has an uneasy whiff of “cute girl doing cute things” to it, but I’m always interested in series set in Kyoto.  This one finds a young adult returning home from Tokyo expecting to take over the family traditional sweets shop, only to find that a young girl has been chosen as successor in his absence.  Pretty experienced staff.  This is a shot in the dark for sure, but I will give it that shot based on the setting if nothing else.

Kunoichi Tsubaki no Mune no Uchi – CloverWorks: (PV) I don’t how a mangaka has three serialized works going at the same time.  Or even if they should.  But all three of Yamamoto Souichirou’s will have gotten adaptations as of this summer.  I haven’t read any of this one, a comedy about a young ninja girl forbidden from contact with males who becomes obsessed with them when she hits her teens.  It would probably be fair to say it’s the least popular of Yamamoto’s series, though that in itself isn’t necessarily telling.

 

 

Will Definitely Blog: Spy X Family, Ao Ashi, Kingdom 4th Season, Kotarou wa Hitorigurashi, Tiger & Bunny 2. 

Sleepers: Kawaii Dake ja Nai Shikimori-san (if it’s obscure enough to be a sleeper), maybe Aharen-san wa Hakarenai?

 

OVA:

Bubble – 4/28/22: (PV) Post-apocalyptic sci-fi from Wit directed by Araki Tetsurou and written by Urobuchi Gen?  There’s a curiosity factor here at the very least.  I have no idea if Bubble will be any good, but it’s nice to see a single episode OVA/ONA that actually does something original rather than another “special episode” of a TV anime.  This is what OVAs used to be, for the most part.

 

 

Theatrical:

Summer is often the big season for anime movies, and spring a slow one – the opposite of TV anime.

Odd Taxi Movie: In the Woods – 04/01/22: (PV) Odd Taxi was the surprise hit of 2021 for good reason – it was a fine show, if not quite the match of its hype factor.  The most exceptional thing about the series for me was its marketing campaign, which was stunningly brilliant from the beginning, and to my thinking accounts for a good chunk of its success.  I expected that to result in a second season (though the central conceit would have been hard to explain away in a direct sequel) but it’s chosen the theatrical route instead.  We don’t know how much of “In the Woods” will be actual new material, as part of the movie is a “reconstruction” of the TV series.

Re:cycle of the Penguindrum – 04/29/22: (PV) Ikuhara Kunhiko’s Mawaru Penguindrum was a microcosm of the man’s entire oeuvre – vexing. undisciplined, visually stunning, and sometimes heartbreaking.  This movie was funded by crowdfunding (which I hate, as a rule), part of a campaign to mark the series’ 10th anniversary.  As if often the case with theatrical extensions of TV anime these days, the production committee is starting with a recap film before releasing the new material later – a clever if cynical way to maximize profits.

I ranked MPD in my 2011 Top 10 despite its myriad flaws (some of which were pretty grievous), because it was one of the most intellectually ambitious and visually creative anime series pretty much ever.  I don’t know that it needed a sequel, but any project Ikuhara is involved in commands one’s full attention (though obviously the main event here is not this movie, but the one which will follow it).

Inu-Ou – 05/28/22: (PV) Inu-Ou may or may not represent Yuasa Masaaki’s farewell to Science SARU, the studio he founded.  We know he left his post as President and is no longer  an employee, but he may choose to work with them again.  In any event this is the second of SARU’s Heike Monogatari-related projects, and after the massive disappointment of The Heike Story, the one for which I still hold out some hope.

In addition to having the master himself directing, Inu-Ou seems likely to benefit from a smarter approach to the material.  Rather than attempting to “adapt” the original in a grossly insufficient block of episodes with a bunch of mediocre original material shoehorned in, Inu-Ou is a truly original work inspired by the Heike.  Presumably Yuasa wrote it to fit its length, a single theatrical film. It’s the tale of a grossly deformed boy and his partnership with a blind biwa player aa they travel Japan recounting tales (of the Heike, presumably).  The trailers have been stunning.

 

 

 

Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedinmail

33 comments

  1. s

    Not sure if I’m really hyped for anything this spring season. Guess I’m back to watching great anime films/shows from the 80’s, 90’s, and early 2000’s while hopefully scanning the spring selection of anime for something decent to follow. Currently on my Satoshi Kon binge and my god this guy was such an amazing storyteller. I hate the fact that life is just full of unfortunate shit and he was taken away so soon; the anime world lost an irreplacable auteur that’s for sure. Anyway, I’ll definitely be checking out Shikimori isn’t just a cutie as I just recently started following the manga and the anime should fulfill my wholesome romcom fix for the season. The material is definitely not mean-spirited at all so no need to worry about that; Shikimori is just an alpha female who genuinely respects her boyfriend and wants nothing more than to protect him. It’s a simple formula that works; the manga are really short chapters so I hope the direction in the anime is tight enough to string them together into a cohesive narrative without tiring out the formula or making the eps feel disjointed

  2. Yeah, the more I hear about Shikimori the more I suspect I may really like it (Call of the Night as well). It’s not going to be the best show of the season but I suspect it will be in my strike zone.

  3. I started Shikimori but mostly it felt pretty flat and boring to me? Like, if all the premise is is that the titular character herself has a few badass moments, dunno, it seems like it doesn’t have enough fun with that gag to make it entertaining. I expect full Takeo-level shenanigans from that kind of concept.

  4. I would agree the first ep was pretty bland. The OP/ED do suggest there might be more here, and I think it’s too soon to make a call on this one. Seems like a candidate for the three episode (at least) rule.

  5. M

    I think Spy X Family and Kingdom are my 2 frontrunners for this season. Spy X Family is a wonderfully entertaining read, and I don’t suspect the anime will disappoint. And even tho I’m still irritated by the Anime Adaptation of Kingdom’s refusal to fully embrace the gore and blood that make the Mangas battles such a visceral experience, the story is still excellent enough to make the coming arcs must-watch.

    2 observations on the Spring 2022 preview, if I may:

    1. Despite its darkness, I suspect Chainsaw Man will be a megahit, specially considering hoe AoT became a global sensation through its darkness and “edge” being a selling point.

    2. I believe that Spring is still the main course of the anime year, it may just feel light because the anime cultural zeitgeist continues to move farther and farther from your tastes (mine as well, to a point). Besides all of the anime you’re looking forward to, there are plenty of meh series that have huge followings, like the aforementioned Komi and Kaguya sequels, that alongside the coming of Overlord, Mushoku Tensei, that one isekai about a librarian, etc. shows that there are plenty of shows that a lot of the anime community is hyped for. I’ve even seen some people in social media declare this to be a Renaissance of Anime or Golden Age of the Medium.

    I personally don’t see it, but then again, im not a big fan of a lot of the genres popping right now,, and as time moves forward, less and less people will remember the classics and quality of yesteryear.

  6. I don’t disagree that my tastes are a long way from what would be considered the mainstream these days. But the hype shows I’m talking about are at least somewhat successful, or they wouldn’t be getting sequels (or 3rd-4th seasons). So there are plenty of people looking ahead to the likes of Mob, MiA, VS, and GK.

  7. T

    I would love an anime adaptation Frieren. It is a beautiful manga that really explores the impact the hero leaves on everyone after his big journey is over through the eyes of the near-immortal elf mage from his party as she retraces the steps the hero’s party took with her apprentices.

    My wife and I are excited for Spy X Family. It is one of the few mangas we actually purchased physical copies instead of just reading it online. It is really well done with good humor, but also has plenty of moments that reflect the seriousness of the cold war situation between the two countries that could go hot at any moment.

    Shikimori isn’t just a cutie looks like it will be a fun one. The idea of a calm/peaceful boy with a wild “yankee” girlfriend isn’t uncommon in manga, but I haven’t seen many of them animated. There was one I read (I Belong to the Baddest Girl at School) where the boy is used to being bullied and everyone’s gopher so when the scariest girl in school asks him out, he assumes it is just more of that while she assumes she successfully got a boyfriend with most of the humor resulting from that misunderstanding. The ones I have read have usually ended up being cute stories.

  8. Freiren is greenlit according to very reliable sources – just hasn’t been formally announced yet.

  9. T

    I am not surprised. Every mention of it I have heard has been pretty positive. It it hasn’t been formally announced yet, does that mean it is probably going to be a few years off?

  10. No, it’s just not at that stage in the pipeline. It will almost certainly happen either fall ‘22 or next year, just like Witch Hat.

  11. q

    I think Kotarou wa Hitorigurashi is one of the best anime I’ve seen in the last 3 years —- maybe even the last 10 years.

  12. I’m only 40% through it but it might get there for me.

  13. M

    Freiren gives me Maquia vibes. Very different stories but with similar themes.

  14. Re: Ao Ashi: It has more interesting/realistic football than Be Blues. Story-wise, Be Blues starts off stronger but the manga title has been tailing off recently. Ao Ashi’s story is still moving along steadily. Not sure which Production I.G. will show up – I don’t think the team responsible for Haikyuu!! and Kaze Ga Tsuyoku Fuiteiru (Run With The Wind) will be involved, and hopefully (from the trailers) we don’t get the Production I.G. team that did Daiya no Ace(Ace of Diamond) (with a lot of static slideshow shots).

    Re: Dance Dance Danseur: I follow this manga title as well. I’m fairly sure it will not be a dumpster fire. However, it is a shoujo style title due to the mangaka’s style and storytelling. The key aspect to lift it above average would be how well they animate the dance sequences. It has to be better than Ballroom e Youkoso. From the trailers, it appears that they are trying to do that.

    With regards to a spate of sport anime covering badminton, that’s likely because Japan has moved up in the world rankings in badminton with 2 of the top world players in Momota Kento (record holder of most titles won in a season, in 2019, and winner of a number of top titles, including All-England – the top badminton championship, you could call it the Wimbledon of badminton) and Yamaguchi Akane (current reigning women’s World Champion).

  15. Like I said in the video, for me it’s great because they’re paving the path for Ao no Hako, which is a series I really like. I’m impressed it’s managed to be a popular title in WSJ given its storytelling style, and it’s probably a lock to get an anime sometime late next year/early 2024.

  16. L

    The Deaimon manga is actually pretty decent, imho. Not really the “cute girl doing cute things” type (at least not in a Kyoani/Moeblob sense).

    Will try Spy x Family. Not sure if I’ll like it (it’s Jump after all), but I’ll give it a try nonetheless.

    Was Mawaru Linuxdrum really that popular? The only thing I remember about it was that I dropped it midway through, and that it was a self obsessed drag of a show. I’d rather spend the day compiling Gentoo while running a marathon than watch anything as fatiguing as that again.

  17. I can totally get dropping MPD. Few series annoyed me more. In the end I’m glad I stuck it out because Ikuhara always tries to do very ambitious things both intellectually and visually, even if his success rate can be alarmingly low.

  18. s

    I started reading SpyxFamily with lukewarm expectations because the premises don’t really convey its true charm. It’s very consistent (it smells of meticulous planning miles away), humorous and moving. It looks simple enough to attract young people, but adults can read it as well (like it is a light take on serious matters). Endou sensei has written darker works and it shows in the way the darkness is only overshadowed by the comedy in SpyxFamily.

  19. All this is basically why I think it can be a megahit.

  20. D

    I enjoy Spy x Family quite abit. I think it is refreshing, sharply written and Anya is as winning a character as any. But I don’t think really think its a masterpiece – I can understand why its so popular (in Japan at least) but the amount of critical attention it has received is a little surprising to me.

  21. Just out of curiosity do you consider KnY, JJK, or TR to be masterpieces? Your point about critical attention is certainly valid but I don’t think it necessarily impacts its commercial potential.

  22. D

    I haven’t read JJK, but do not consider either KnY or TR to be masterpieces or even particularly good – SxF is a better than both of them IMO. And I agree with your point about commercial appeal. SxF is already huge in Japan – it is maybe the best selling manga which doesn’t yet have an anime adaptation, and the anime will no doubt further boost its popularity and appeal in the west.

    But what sets SxF (and CSM as well) apart from other Jump powerhouses is that they have also been held in very high regard from a critical standpoint, having been nominated/won basically every manga award out there. And its SxF receiving this level of critical acclaim which surprised me a little

  23. B

    Last month, I told myself that Spring was very loaded and at the same time was surprised that whe I was looking in details, couldn’t find a series that I was excited for (apart a sequel a dropped series here).

    As I said in a previous video comment, my only interest with “SxF” is an analytical study as it is since “Assassination C”, the last example of a 1 million physical copies seller before an anime, and for the latter, anime had almost no impact on the sales. And so, I am extremely curious to see which margin of commercial progression still has a series which as stated above, has already received many prizes, been mentioned in TV shows and so on when these are already strong sales boosters.

    Also, maybe a bit nitpicking but I like to repeat that Jump and Jump+ are two distinct things. Yeah, both are Shueisha but some series in Jump+ really have a different treatment and targets and freedom for authors (stated by interviews from authors and Jump+ editor himself). This is actually interesting how Jump+ kind of became at a moment, a new house for former Jump or Jump SQ fallen soldiers (“Summertime rendering” author crashed in Jump before managing that small success in Jump+. Because, let’s be serious, this is not a mega-hit either…yet). And I should add, regarding that analytical aspects, that I find funny how lately, Jump series became huge sellers after anime while Jump+ manage to have almost back-to-back million sellers without it with “SxF” and “Kaijuu N°8”. (Even though, contrary to some legends, Jump+ also has cancellations, but they are not so limited by series number as it is online compared to Jump).

    Anyway, I will end by saying that the only way to dislike to the point to drop “SxF” is if a person cannot stand Anya. And this is…my case. Her artificial forced charm cutie plot armor did not work on me. And as she clearly became the main character contrary to what the initial purpose seemed to be, for me it was too much. But also, there is a mix of genre into it that is too chimeric for me. But anyway, I am very happy for Testsuya Endou to finally have a commercial success as I really enjoyed his previous “failed” series.

  24. Well, I’ve noted that SxF isn’t a WSJ series ad nauseam (both here and in multiple videos) so you don’t have to tell me. That does make a difference in how smooth the potential path is to being a true kaibutsu on the level of KnY or JJK. Indeed Jump+ is not the same thing.

  25. K

    It will depend on several factors, such as the quality of the anime, but I think Chainsaw Man has the potential to be as popular as Attack on Titan at least in the west. In fact in America it sells more than JJk or KNY.
    https://icv2.com/articles/markets/view/50674/february-2022-npd-bookscan-top-20-adult-graphic-novels

  26. A

    I might check out Love All Play, but it doesn’t seem the most interesting. I have been liking Ryman Club quite a bit. And to be fair, it hasn’t been *that* long since the last badminton anime (Hanebado in 2018). But yeah before that I don’t recall it much at all. I might have to pick up Be Blues manga, while I am not that big into the sport, I have loved Major. So, if this is the Major of soccer as you say then I kinda want to check it out.

  27. It sure checks my boxes as a Major Major fan

  28. As a reader of Spy X Family I think it has some real mainstream appeal. It has something for everyone, without veering too far either into screwball comedy nor into hyperviolent gritty action. It also has some really strong and obvious parallels to the real life Cold War (it’s set in an very thinly disguised East Berlin), so honestly I wonder if by pure chance its weirdly timely thematic relevance might not actually favour it (or be to its detriment – hard to decide). It’s not necessarily super deep, of course, but that’s not needed to breach the mainstream – it’s a damn good work of entertainment that can reach everyone and has almost nothing to put off people (no fanservice, no creepy stuff), so that could be enough.

  29. i

    Will you be watching the 3rd installment of Legend of the Galactic Heroes?

  30. I’d have some catching up to do.

  31. S

    While it doesn’t quite reach the same height as the original adaptation, it’s still better than most series and the 2nd season was a step up in my opinion, despite some rushed content. Though after all the years, it’ll probably a bit hard to get back to it when the 1st season ended with a cliffhanger.

  32. D

    LoGH is my favourite anime of all time, by some distance. The world-building, the imagined historical events, the multiple storylines are first rate, but what really sets it apart is the clever character development. An enormous cast, yet each one, no matter how little airtime they recieve, feel like an entirely believable character, acting rationally as you would expect someone from their class or background to behave. This results in multiple perspectives on each event that ring true and gives you different ways to interpret the rights and wrongs of the specific actions. It also engages in a lot of counterfactual musing, which also sets the story apart, giving you a sense of reality to proceedings.

    The revamp retains much of what is great about the original. It perhaps lacks that darkers, grittier character that truly jolted you out of your seat with the original; long, languid shots of duelling space fleets suddenly punctuated by horrific shots of ordinary soldiers burning and bleeding as their ships were destroyed. But the new version does remain true to the character of the original, maintaining that sense of standing outside and oberving events unfold from a multitude of angles, allowing you to live and breathe this imagined landscape. It’s a truly excellent revisit of one of the finest space operas of all time and worthy of your attention.

Leave a Comment