I think the lack of comments on Sonny Boy is reflective of my experience with it. This series is interesting in an abstract and intellectual way, but I just don’t think many viewers care about it all that much. Appreciate it, yes – its uniqueness, its striking visual style, its willingness to avoid modern anime cliches. But if a show is never willing to meet you half way, sooner or later you get a little tired of trekking all the way to wherever it wants to hang out. Frankly, it’s exhausting.
My thinking was that a paring down of the cast to the essential core (which now includes Yamabiko the dog) might help in this respect. It still might, but Sonny Boy’s immediate response was to use a flashback to expand things outward again with an all-new subplot. It was interesting (there’s that word again), but we already have so much to parse after seven relentless episodes. And if anything the developments in this episode were some of the most cryptic in the series so far.
We already knew Yamabiko was old, though I don’t remember if he specifically said 5000 years before now. After Mizuho pushes him to tell she and Nagara how he became a dog, that’s exactly what Yamabiko does. From his days of wondering aimlessly alone to his meeting with a group led by a charismatic young woman named Kamara. Kamara has a special power, to seemingly bend the this world and its inhabitants to her will. But as we’ll find out there are exception, and the reason for that at least is laid out plainly, if nothing else.
The most effective part of the episode for me was the early portion of this sequence, with the isolated Yamabiko (in human form) resisting the pull of Kamara and her seemingly idyllic commune. While the reasons aren’t clear it’s obvious that Yamabiko sees his isolation as a deserved punishment, but more than that there is something a little off-putting and creepy about Kamara and her followers. There’s an air of cultishness to them, as if they’re trying a little too hard to deny the emptiness of their existences.
Eventually, inevitably, Yamabiko falls in love with Kamara. But soon she and the others fall ill (the first occurrence of illness in this reality that we’ve seen), mysterious crystalline tumors forming all over their bodies. Only Yamabiko is unaffected, and eventually, after resolving he would do anything for Kamara, he turns into a dog (it just happens). The others discover a strange man in a cave, who seems to be the source of all the tumors. Eventually he tells Yamabiko that his name is War, and that the reason Yamabiko is immune to the illness is that he created this world himself.
That all seems clear enough. So does the fact that Yamabiko lives with regret over the fact that he probably could have saved Kamara, and never did. But what does it all mean, really? What is it in the context of the larger story? There’s no hand-holding with this narrative, that’s for sure. Soon the trio meet back up with Nozomi, though she scolds them for being two weeks late – which is due to the fact that their time has been moving more slowly than hers (obviously an important point). And the spark between she and Nagara is apparent immediately when they reunite, to the extent that matters. I’ve rarely has less idea where a series was going next at any given point, which is interesting in its own right. But I wish I cared a little bit more about the answer.
Nick Leung
September 4, 2021 at 2:31 pmI wholeheartedly disagree. Arthouse productions are already rare in this industry. For pieces like this, they should stay true to its vision and allow the niche audience to eventually turn this into a cult hit. There are plenty of examples of where this would work out such as all of Satoshi Kon’s works (Madhouse). Turning something unique into a generic anime just doesn’t do much for the industry or animation as a whole. Quite frankly, the story isn’t nearly as confusing as people make it out to be. Since there’s so much to unpack, I do wish reviewers would actually try instead of complaining about how unique it is.
Ryan
September 4, 2021 at 6:15 pmI agree with you Nick – I genuinely think some people don’t make an effort to really get this show or try and understand it. It’s a very subtle show but the main theme of each episode is never truly lost on me and I feel like this is why anime like this are rarer and rarer theses days. People just love shows that do the same thing but really well – and never try shows that make the effort to be different.
It’s not like the show is different for the sake of it but it is genuinely great and beautiful with many subtle moments. This episode showed great strength in giving purpose and backstory to Yamabiko as well as tie his story to Nagara who has now have an ally and partner who he can relate with as he slowly moves on to conquer his past and demons.
kiwi
September 7, 2021 at 2:59 pmbriefly glancing at the reviews, checking in to this blog at odd times as i often do, I still intend to give this show a watch when I have time.
I like arthouse anime (basically if something is willing to take risks and break anime formula, I feel obligated to at least give it a shot haha), especially in an industry that is so bogged down and essentially stuck in a stranglehold of its own creation.
Guardian Enzo
September 7, 2021 at 4:57 pmITA with all that, and Sonny Boy is very much worth your time. It just hasn’t connected with me the way the best arthouse series do.
nixx
September 14, 2021 at 5:39 amI don’t want to look completely ignorant, but this episode was pure nonsense for me, filled with extreme sadness and regret though. (Master of regretting – such a brilliant title.) The explanations at the end were not so helpful, unfortunately. Why the guy was called War at all? When did Kamara exactly tell or imply she wanted to be taken out from that world? And other silly questions. Maybe it’s because I’m not so good with the language, I don’t know.
Either way, the show doesn’t excite me as much as it did for the first 4 or 5 episodes. Much of the characters are gone. It’s not clear what the remaining trio (and the dog) is trying to achieve. The overall tone kinda lacks hope. We’ll see what comes next though.