No politics to speak of. And the best episode of the season for Attack on Titan. Is that a coincidence? Obviously not. The allegorical choices Iseyama makes are a crushing weight bearing down on this series, so a break from them is a welcome respite – and freed of that weight the narrative has a chance to finally take flight. The respite is going to be short-lived, unfortunately – the way the plot has been rigged makes that unavoidable – but I’ll enjoy it while it lasts.
The curious sensation here – and once again I’ll say I’m not sure whether this is the intention or not – is watching a tremendous (in every sense of the word) battle play out here with no rooting interest in either side. We had three seasons to have Eren’s case made to the audience. And while I admit he’s never remotely won me over as a character, I don’t think that even really matters because Eren has become a terrorist and the self-appointed bringer of destruction to the world. Even if you think he’s justified (and I just might) it’s hard to literally root for a guy like that.
Three seasons for Eren, only six episodes for most of the Liberio crew. Even so there is a sort of recency bias here, which almost but not quite makes you forget that Marley is basically Nazi Germany. And the fact is, Falco is probably the closest thing to a genuinely decent person Shingeki no Kyoujin has introduced since Armin – good and unspoiled, anyway. He’s an innocent both literally and symbolically so Falco at least I sort of hate to see taken out. Reiner is a very sympathetic guy (admittedly sometimes you can just leave the “sym” out) but you can’t forget Wall Maria and other moments from earlier on the series. He’s got plenty of blood on his hands.
Speaking of Armin, he finally does make his first appearance of the season. And it’s quite an entrance – he sneaks into the harbor on a tiny sailing boat and transforms into the Colossal Titan, wiping out the entire Marleyan fleet (whatever portion of it was in the port anyway) in one fell swoop (though he does stomp all the ships to dust just for good measure). If Armin was in any way morally distinct from the others, that’s gone with the wind now. He’s killed thousands personally and masterminded (he does make time to praise Erwin – pardon me while I puke) this deadly invasion plan. It would be one thing if it was in the name of some greater good, but- that’s not really what we’re talking about here, is it?
The plan, as you would expect given the deviser, is a peach. The Marleyans are one step behind at every turn, their titans are being taken down one by one (including Zeke seemingly, though it’s hard to believe he could be gone from the series that anti-climactically), and they seem to be running out of cards to play. Poor Reiner would just like to become a tree and leave this mortal plane, but Falco and Gabi (she really should have been named Screechi) just won’t let him moulder in peace. Reiner is burdened with the greatest curse a character in this series can have – self-awareness.
Leave Shingeki to its own devices and it can always do what it did here, deliver shock and awe with the best of them. The whole sequence with Eren using the Jaw Titan – after its limbs were systematically liberated (it’s just a flesh wound) – to destroy the War Hammer was a masterpiece of screaming, over-the-top, nerve-scraping chaos. That rush, along with a sort of morbid curiosity, is what keeps me coming back even with all the unwelcome baggage The Final Season is carting with it.
rogerp
January 27, 2021 at 3:55 am“Burdened with the greatest curse a character in this series can have – self-awareness”… haha that was great, Enzo, thanks! had a good laugh reading the review, as I did at the mention of Erwin in the episode… I guess in a sense it’s nice to be able to enjoy this senseless carnage at a distance, without being even half-invested in the story or the fate of the characters. Looking forward to the next episode and your review!
Guardian Enzo
January 27, 2021 at 7:43 amThe funny thing is, it’s hard not to conclude that Isayama himself considers Erwin some sort of hero and strategic genius. And what does that say about him?
Derrick
January 27, 2021 at 10:51 amI lost the plot since this, but with the settings the way it is can’t do much except mutual destruction.
If only all characters can be more self aware about what they’re doing
Krize
January 27, 2021 at 3:12 pmThe second I saw Erwin’s name mentioned in this episode I had to groan, thinking “Enzo isn’t going to like that”. Really, I wish the show would let his memory stay dead too.
Orion Taylor
January 28, 2021 at 6:17 amI’ve been waiting a long time to see these past two episodes get animated, and I think that they delivered pretty darn well. Admittedly, some of the key moments from this mini-arc looked a little bit better (or maybe just different) in the season preview (which from my understanding was made entirely separately from the any of the episodes). A few thoughts:
-Post-timeskip Eren continues to demonstrate just how strategic and ruthless he is. He might not be on the same level as Tywin or Azula, but it’s still entertaining to watch.
-Remember how, back in the uprising arc, Armin had qualms about killing someone to save Jean’s life? He even puked after doing the deed. This time around, he’s not significantly shaken by massive amount of destruction he just caused. Jean admonished Floch for causing too much collateral damage, but what Armin did is several orders of magnitude worse than Floch, regardless of whether or not it was done with malicious intent.
-My favorite part of the episode was definitely when Sasha, Jean and co. take down Pieck and the Panzer squad. The action was pretty cool (it was particularly neat how Pieck tilted the cartman titan to give the gunners a better angle). It was kind of sad to see the Panzer squad die (and for Sasha to bloody her hands), though as you mentioned it’s hard to root for either side here (which is the point of this arc).
For all its faults, Attack on Titan can still be pretty darn entertaining.
Guardian Enzo
January 28, 2021 at 6:56 amIt can, no denying it. Which is remarkable, all things considered.