This is another one of those Otoyomegatari chapters that’s an absolute feast of eye candy – scenery, cat, fabric and human – though there’s some plot progression here too to be sure. At least as long as Inoue Takehiko is on hiatus from Vagabond there’s really no active competition for Mori-sensei as a manga artist in my book – one almost begins to take it for granted at times, but it’s good to step back and really look at these panels, especially in a chapter like this one. That Mori is able to produce work like this month after month is pretty incredible.
I admit I didn’t (and don’t) know much about Antalya, an ancient port city on Turkey’s Mediterranean coast. It’s currently the country’s fifth-largest city, but to judge from Talas’ comments about it being much more impressive than Ankara (which today has about four time as many residents) perhaps that wasn’t true a century or more ago. It makes a wonderful canvas for Mori’s pen, a cityscape of multicultural faces and tall ships (which haven’t been a part of this series, for obvious reasons), ancient plazas and buildings, and of course the cats. Being a port city Antalya is overrun with cats, for reasons Mr. Smith explains to Talas (who for obvious reasons, knows little of the ways of ports).
I have to say the interplay between these two is pretty damn cute, especially when Smith keeps going off on academic tangents and then catching himself in embarrassment. Thing is, I don’t believe Talas says she’s interested just to spare Henry’s feelings (though I think she would if she needed to) – she genuinely is interested. She’s possessed of a keen mind and hasn’t had much chance to exercise it, and she’s lucked into a relationship with a man who respects her right to think for herself. Surely it’s Smith’s curiosity and intellect, almost if not quite as much as his kindness, that’s caused Talas to come to love him.
One interesting incident in the city comes when Talas spots a “Turkish swing” – basically what appears to be a large log suspended by two ropes and used as a kind of aerial teeter-totter. The depiction of the two of them on it (I’ve come to think of it as Mr. Smith’s wild ride) is certainly stunning, especially when Mori depicts what Henry is seeing in his mind’s eye. But I was immediately suspicious when one of the men in charge suggested he hold Henry’s bag while he and Talas rode the swing – he got the bag back, but I hope he checked its contents.
It seemed to me that Ali and Nikovski were unsettled about something and had the party leave Antalya more quickly than planned – I wonder if the swing situation had anything to do with that. There’s also a scene where a Moroccan merchant offers to buy Talas’ shawl for his (stunning) wife, and she accepts, though the shawl was one she made herself. I suspect this was here to show Talas’ devotion to Henry and the larger cause rather than material possessions, but I’m not ruling out that this was a more significant event too in some fashion.
Panino Manino
December 14, 2018 at 5:59 am“and she’s lucked into a relationship with a man who respects her right to think for herself.”
Hey, this is true. It’s easy to say that Smith was luck to find her, but is Talas the luckiest one between the two.
“I suspect this was here to show Talas’ devotion to Henry and the larger cause rather than material possessions, but I’m not ruling out that this was a more significant event too in some fashion.”
I heard comments about this being the reason for Ali and Nikolasky’s strange looks. About this symbolizing that she ended her mourning period and was ready to remarry, in this case she was demonstrating her acceptance of Smith as her new groom.
Guardian Enzo
December 14, 2018 at 6:49 amThat’s an interesting take I hadn’t thought of. Very plausible.
Panino Manino
December 14, 2018 at 9:02 amI sure hope isn’t something “bad”. I got nervous when those marrocan appeared, I feared trouble.
I strongly hope Mori will surprise me and avoid all the death flags that Smith is collecting.
Please, no tragedies.
AYA
February 9, 2019 at 4:06 amI…don’t like the woman Talas, honestly. She feels too much like a “mysterious exotic woman who fell in love with the white guy who rescue her” that is too popular in literature about colonial time. And she’s barely a character at this point. We knew nothing about her, except for her obsession with Smith, and she’s the perfect traditional wife material: naive, obedient, good at housework.
Unlike you, and most people here, I don’t have much confidence in Mori’s skill as a writer of stories. I think what she’s best at, in most of her manga, is her incredible art and her very good sense of visual storytelling. Aside from that, the story and the character…she struggles sometimes. So unless something very unexpected happens, I have not much hope about this storyline. Smith getitng into some trouble might be a good change of pace, the last dozen of chapters has been quite sluggish. The story lost most of its momentum when it leaves the village where Amira lives. I don’t feel there any conflict worth following in the story anymore. Yes, the Russia is coming, but I mean personal conflict.
I still follow this manga everytime just to look at the art though.