Minami-ke Tadaima – 06

Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 06 Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 18 Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 34

Wait a minute – just where did Kana pull that second sea cucumber from?

Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 01Ho-hum – another week, another sterling example of Minami-ke Tadaima.  I wasn’t sure anything could make me laugh as hard as the whiteboard scene in Zetsuen to Tempest, but this ep came pretty darn close.  And it was much needed too, after this week’s Psycho-Pass, Robotics;Notes and Shin Sekai Yori

You could have told me that episode featured the following and I would have been pretty convinced it was going to be great:

  • Moe-kyun Kana-chan
  • Takusan Mako-chan

Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 02I’ve said it before, but I really think many of Minami-ke’s best moments come when Mako-chan is involved.  He’s a singular creation of comic genius, and among anime traps I think Makoto/-chan is the most interesting take on the psychology of the trope – and he brings out the best in Kana’s baka genius, too.  One of the most interesting elements of the character is that Makoto/-chan’s best and worst days tend to be the same days – we saw it in earlier seasons (Haruka tuning in Tokyo in the changing room comes to mind) and we saw it here again this week.

Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 03Before that, though, we had some another thoroughly delightful spectacle – Kana-san the bishoujo.  The premise: Uchida and Yoshino are over and the subject of Maki and Atsuko having part-time jobs – an exotic and fascinating topic to grade-schoolers – comes up.  Kana decides it’s time for interview practice, but Chiaki intervenes and says she needs to interview Kana to see if she’s fit to be an interviewer.  Kana’s only answer when I’m about herself: “I’m a bishoujo!”.  She then proceeds to change into a dress, let her hair down and become a sort of mini-Haruka with dark hair and extra sugar.  Maybe it’s just me, but Kana seems cuter than ever this year – she’s always been hilarious, but I don’t ever recall her being this kawaii and frankly, this pretty.  While this act confuses the heck out of the visiting Fujioka, he reacts by finally confessing (again) that he loves the “real” Kana.  Sadly, though, even in bishoujo mode Kana is still clueless, and Fujioka’s effort is a swing and miss.

Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 05That skit plays directly off one featuring Kana’s circle, and the topic of horoscopes.  Riko’s warns her to steer clear of water, which is a problem as the gang are going to the pool – and this is another opportunity to note that Kana definitely doesn’t share Haruka’s fear of the two-piece (which we’ll discover later she seems to have overcome at last).  Especially as there’s no one in blue around, and someone in blue is supposed to protect Libras that day.  Fortunately Fujioka shows up here too, though this time it’s a coincidence, and shows remarkable composure as Kana and Keiko spend the better part of 30 seconds staring at the crotch of his blue swimsuit from close range.  It’s Riko’s lucky day after all – thought it’s also another example of everyone in this series being in love with the person who isn’t in love with them.

Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 07The main event, certainly, is the beach trip featuring all three sisters and all of Chiaki’s close circle (apart from Touma, who may have been getting a little overexposed anyway).  This is a shining example of all the pleasures and perils of being this particular shougakusei cross-dresser.  Kana has told Makoto to wear a swimsuit but not that a beach trip is planned, so he’s quite peeved at not having a chance to “prepare for these things”.  Things begin to take on the air of a spoof of 70’s porn flicks (which I’ve only heard about) as Mako-chan wistfully (perhaps the funniest facial expression in anime this season) watches Kana and Chiaki splashing in the water, before Haruka calls her over and offers in a husky voice to “Rub suntan oil on you, if you like.”  There are times I wonder if Haruka is in banchou-mode and knows Makoto’s secret, and tortures him on purpose.  I suppose not, but there are certain things boys that age simply aren’t qualified to endure – as the results prove clear.  The best days are the worst indeed, and vice-versa.

Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 08There’s a very interesting dynamic between Makoto, Mako-chan, Haruka and Chiaki.  Yeah, Makoto has a huge crush on Haruka – who wouldn’t – but he also says “I’ll never take this off as long as I live!” when Chiaki puts a band-aid on Makoto’s boo-boo at school.  For all her hostility towards Makoto, I see it more as the kind of grade-school distraction that boys and girls resort to with kids they like, to cover up the fact that they like them.  There can be no question whatsoever that she adores Mako-chan – she positively dotes on her and follows her like a puppy, the slightly “older” girl who’s so feminine and capable.  Somewhat more seriously than with Haruka I wonder if Chiaki knows the truth, except on a subconscious level – perhaps her affection for Makoto finds a much safer outlet in Mako-chan.  In any event in scenes like the one where Mako-chan teaches Chiaki to swim (incidentally, it’s fascinating how Makoto’s personality really changes when he’s Mako-chan – he goes from the hyper-genki grade-school boy to the responsible and sober middle-school girl) it’s hard not to see a real connection between them, even if he is in disguise – and when he has to give her a massive “Pose of Denial!” later on to hide the fact that Mako-chan is wearing Makoto’s band-aid in the exact same spot, she’s absolutely crushed.

Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 09In any event, that’s the sort of discussion that goes deeper than Minami-ke itself is ever likely to go – the manga is even less relationship-focused than the mangaka’s other series, “Kyou no Go no Ni”.  Instead we get a reminder of just what a mixed blessing being Mako-chan is – Makoto now has a tan-line with shoulder straps.  I hope getting to second-base with Haruka – for the second time – was worth it…

Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 10 Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 11 Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 12
Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 13 Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 14 Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 15
Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 16 Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 17 Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 19
Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 20 Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 21 Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 22
Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 23 Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 24 Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 25
Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 26 Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 27 Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 28
Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 29 Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 31 Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 32
Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 33 Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 34 Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 35
Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 36 Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 37 Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 38
Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 39 Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 40 Minami-ke Tadaima - 06 - Large 41


  1. M

    Myssa here.

    I think a BETTER comparison with regards to relationships is Sakuraba's OTHER manga "That Future is a Lie", which focuses entirely on a cast of high schoolers.

  2. And one I can't attest to as sadly, I've read one of that one yet…

  3. i

    Aren't you reading a little too much into the relationships. I think that all the members of Minami-Ke are just baka enough to make all these wacky relationships work.

    I agree though that Kana has been a lot more Kawaii than before and the bishoujo skit was hilarious with the ultimate Fujioka kicker.

    Best Minami-ke skit includes: Hosaka, Natsuki, Haruka, Fujioka, Kana, Touma, Makochan/Makoto and Chiaki. Imagine what hell would break loose if those eight gathered in one room with all the other characters watching from the hallway or something.

  4. Isn't reading too much into relationships part of the fun with anime? Besides, there's a lot of implied relationship stuff with this mangaka – at least as I see it.

    As far as making the relationships work, I agree to some extent that the baka factor makes anything possible – but within reason. It's not like Haruka and Makoto or Chiaki and Fujioka are ever going to get together.

  5. Z

    Sure, if relationships is what you're looking for in your entertainment. Which not everyone is.

  6. d

    The rounder character designs from the first season have gradually become increasingly streamlined as the seasons have progressed. I think this has hurt Kana and Chiaki the most. Only Natsuki has benefited from the change as a more angular look fits his character best.

  7. u

    Don't forget Mako-chan. I think prettying him up good was one of the few good things Okawari did.

  8. H

    Going only off the first season and the fourth season so far for me, but it seems that one of the reasons why Chiaki likes Mako-chan so much is because she's assertive and almost manly in a way that Makoto isn't (Chiaki's repeatedly said the reason she hassles Makoto so much is because he's not manly enough). Maybe it's that Makoto isn't manly enough to be a man, but the same level is manly enough when he's being a girl, or maybe he's actually acting differently (this is what it seems like to me). If he was to act more like Mako-chan when he was Makoto, I think Chiaki would really fall for him.

    Mini-Haruka Kana was certainly a treat this episode. As was Haruka with Mako-chan. I think it was helpful to remember that Mako's an elementary school boy, otherwise I was thinking he's in trouble, "History of the World, Part 1" style.

Leave a Comment