Minami-ke Tadaima – 02

Minami-ke Tadaima - 02 - Large 11 Minami-ke Tadaima - 02 - Large 20 Minami-ke Tadaima - 02 - Large 32

Minami-ke Tadaima is flexing its comic muscles in a big way after only two episodes.

No question about it, Minami-ke is really back.  This material in the hands of staff who really understand it – the timing, the tone, the balance of different elements – is one of the true powerhouses of anime comedy (which is admittedly sometimes a pretty underpowered grouping).  One of the major strengths of M-K is the deep and varied supporting cast, who form various orbits around the three sisters and sometimes cross over, usually with delightful results.  This diversity allows the series to excel comedically in several different styles because each subset of the cast brings something different to the mix.

Just as loyalists of Minami-ke each seem to have favorites among the sisters, so it is with the supporting cast as well – and the spotlight this week fell on some of mine.  First and best we have the irrepressible Makoto/-chan (Morinaga Rika), for my money the funniest take on the trap character in anime history.  Then there’s the other Minami clan, the one with the Y-chromosomes – eldest brother Haruo (Kawada Shinji), second brother Natsuki (Hiroyuki Yoshino) – a classmate at Haruka’s – put-upon youngest brother Akira (Hayama Tatsuya) and finally, little sister Touma (Mizuki Nana).  She might be the most butch of the lot of them, to the point where Chiaki refers to her as “my little brother”.

Seeing all these oddballs interact is part of the fun of Minami-ke.  Each sister has their own subset of school chums, among which the three youngest Minami “B” clan members belong.  Touma also belongs in her family subset, and she forms a small gender-bending subset with Mako-chan, which is usually aligned with Kana.  Makoto is part of Chiaki’s school subset as himself, but also part of the Minami “A” household as Mako-chan, and both halves of his nature interact with Chiaki and her friends Yoshino and Uchida at different times.  He also forms a small subset with “Plain Yogurt” Shuiichi (Ohara Momoko) as the male division of Chiaki’s elementary school set.

The reason both Makoto/-chan and Touma work so well as gender-bender characters, I think, is that both of their situations are so seamlessly integrated into the plot and they’re both so conflicted about their duality. Makoto tries hard to be a real man (“women’s clothing can no longer suppress his wildness as a man”) and is desperate to break out of the “trap” Kana laid for him.  Yet he’s so damn good at being a girl – Chiaki laments that Makoto-kun “isn’t manly at all”, but marvels that Mako-chan is so ladylike, and wishes Kana would take a lesson from her (it’s also worth noting that Chiaki pointedly tells her friends she “doesn’t hate” Makoto, which for her is almost a confession).  In addition to having a natural instinct at being a trap, Makoto’s ruse also allows him to be close to Haruka, on whom he has a hopeless if completely understandable crush – heck, it even got him to second base with her in Season 2.

Poor Mako-chan – even as he tries (for the 56th time – Kana’s counting) to save “what little masculinity I have” by taking off his hairpin and coming clean, Haruka pulls him back in again and he’s helpless to resist.  For my money Makoto is the best supporting character in Minami-ke both because he’s hilarious and because there’s real pathos in his situation – he’s so earnest about every baka thing he gets himself immersed in.  But Touma is a great character too, not to be underestimated.  Her ruse is more selective – apart from Chiaki’s play-acting, it’s only Fujioka who actually thinks she’s a boy.  Touma purports to keep scam going because it allows her to talk and practice soccer with Fujioka, but in truth it’s pretty obvious that she’s crushing on him just as hard as Chiaki is – as witness her reaction when Kana plays her “April Fool’s” joke and tells Fujioka she’s a girl.  Poor Fujioka – if he were a lolicon, he’d have no relationship troubles at all, as he’s got the 6th-grade set helpless against his charms.

That whole April Fool’s gag is an example of how Minami-ke can extend it’s gags to the level of meta-humor successfully, and never more so then when the traps are involved.  It’s also interesting to watch Kana interact with Touma and especially Makoto/-chan, because in that setting she’s almost mature and sensible – which is a cover, of course, for her scheming to keep both of them dancing like puppets at the end of her strings. That’s another thing that’s so fun about this show, and why when it’s “on” it never gets repetitive – all of the characters behave differently depending on the context in which we see them.  It’s most obvious with Makoto but it extends to everyone in the cast, not excluding Kana’s two sisters.  Haruka is a very different person interacting with her schoolmates (who we haven’t seen much of yet, indicating that this subset is likely to emerge next week) than she is at home, playing the den mother to her younger sisters and their large collection of friends.

Lastly, we had a welcome return to the spotlight for the male Minamis this week.  They were almost totally absent from Season 3, and they were missed – their dynamic is yet another completely distinct facet of M-K’s rainbow of comedy.  Akira is one I really feel for – his two older brothers, despite being idiots themselves, treat him with complete disdain and he barely seems to exist in their social structure.  The older Minamis alternately dote on and confound Touma, as neither of them seem to understand the other in the slightest – despite Touma’s boyishness she’s still the only girl in a house full of men, and the strain often shows.  It was interesting to see a different side of her this week, after the brothers challenged her to be more ladylike – going to Yoshino (not Uchida) for advice, which led her to Makoto (hilariously) then Chiaki.  For tomboy Touma her sewing was “craft work”, but it turns out it was ladylike sewing all along – which makes her a big hit at the female Minami house. 

There are still many elements of the recipe that haven’t emerged yet, starting with the uniqueness that is Hosaka.  We also haven’t had any of the food porn that Minami-ke is legendary for, which is often connected to Hosaka (who intermingles with several other subsets, but more than anyone in the cast forms a set of one).  Given how deep the well of humor that this series has to draw on is, those elements could still be weeks away – but there’ll be plenty to keep us amused in the meantime, even if that’s the case.

Minami-ke Tadaima - 02 - Large 09 Minami-ke Tadaima - 02 - Large 10 Minami-ke Tadaima - 02 - Large 12
Minami-ke Tadaima - 02 - Large 13 Minami-ke Tadaima - 02 - Large 14 Minami-ke Tadaima - 02 - Large 15
Minami-ke Tadaima - 02 - Large 16 Minami-ke Tadaima - 02 - Large 17 Minami-ke Tadaima - 02 - Large 18
Minami-ke Tadaima - 02 - Large 19 Minami-ke Tadaima - 02 - Large 21 Minami-ke Tadaima - 02 - Large 22
Minami-ke Tadaima - 02 - Large 23 Minami-ke Tadaima - 02 - Large 24 Minami-ke Tadaima - 02 - Large 25
Minami-ke Tadaima - 02 - Large 26 Minami-ke Tadaima - 02 - Large 27 Minami-ke Tadaima - 02 - Large 29
Minami-ke Tadaima - 02 - Large 30 Minami-ke Tadaima - 02 - Large 31 Minami-ke Tadaima - 02 - Large 33


  1. f

    Excellent coverage. I have a question. I didn't watch the second and third seasons of Minami-ke. Will I be able to understand this season?

  2. This isn't a series that relies too heavily on continuity so I think you'd be fine.

  3. S

    There are some running jokes that help little jokes turn into big ones. Mainly the big running joke this episode was with Makoto.

    The content of each episode is self contained. I can't think of individual stories that carry episodes; only character interactions and jokes.

  4. H

    I only saw the first season as well, but haven't missed obvious jokes, at least as far as I can tell.

  5. S

    Maaaaaan, Here I was hoping for some more of the high school crew.

  6. L

    Have to say this 4th season has been a pleasant surprise. So far, it "feels" better than the 2nd and 3rd seasons, though doesn't quite have the freshness of the 1st (for obvious reasons). Still find the whole Mako-chan thing a bit tiresome, but Touma remains my favourite character, along with her brothers. Need more Hosaka, though.

    The one thing I've always liked (from all seasons) was that bluesy guitar lick; the one playing while Makoto-kun was discussing "manliness" with the other two classmates. It sounds like they've upped the BGM volume for that track. It seemed rather muted in the 2nd and 3rd seasons.

    I wonder if we're going to see Touma making clothes and the Minami sibling gawking in awe at her hidden "lady-like" ability. That would be awesome!!

    Btw, what's with those static "template" backgrounds? It's like they ran out of staff and decided to scour DeviantArt or MS-Powerpoint for leftovers.

  7. B

    In terms of comedy Chiaki is probably my favorite but Haruka is damned adorable and I cannot lie.

  8. A

    I wished they bring back the serious eye close up scene from the first season, then this current season would be just right

Leave a Comment