As expected, the “Hoshi Matsu Hito” OVAs are going to be followed by a full (two cour) TV series of Mahoutsukai no Yome – we’ve known that for a while. And having seen the first three episodes in a theatre, I can say with little fear of contradiction that most fans of the manga aren’t going to be disappointed. But while it was the literal adaptation of the manga that those fans were surely most anxious for, this original prequel by director Naganuma Norihiro and Takaha Aya more than stands on its own – in fact, it impresses as an outstanding piece of art on its own terms.
I’m not sure “Mahoutsukai” needed a prequel, per se – I think the manga gets you wrapped up in the story pretty quickly. But I do think “Hoshi Matsu Hito” enhances the experience of watching this series, and that’s because it manages to make sense as an origin story for Chise. More than that, it tells a very powerful and moving story of its own, elegant in its simplicity. As gloriously detailed as the art in these OVAs is, the narrative is quite minimal. It’s a story of loneliness, kindness given freely and love of books – all themes in the parent series too, but distilled down to their essence here.
Readers of the manga will know that in the end the story contained in “Hoshi Matsu Hito” is more than simply a prequel, but I won’t go into details there for obvious reasons. What’s important is that Miura Riichi’s tale is a powerful and moving one, and the impact he had on Chise is ongoing. Miura loved a young woman, the daughter of his wealthy employer. He assumed there could be no future for them, but the truth of it is that Niikura Mayumi loved Riichi every bit as much as he loved her. In the end she gave him a book (and the message contained therein) to remember her by, and with it extracted a promise to one day return the book to her. It seemed as though that promise would not be kept, but fate intervened in the form of Chise.
The OVAs don’t explain in detail exactly what happened to Miura-san – how he came to end up a “captive” (in his own words) in that strange and wonderful library in the forest. Manga readers will be able to piece it together a little easier, but that’s a cheat of sorts. Elias does tell us that the truth lies in the Legends of Tono (a very famous book compiled by folklorist Yanagita Tonio, chronicling the legends of Iwate Prefecture) – specifically the tale of the Mayoiga (a hidden house or village which brings good luck to visitors). The gist of it is that one cannot leave the Mayoiga unless they bring one item with them – something Miura seemed to know full well when he gave Chise that library card and those books to take with her. But there was no one there to give such a gift to him, and thus he remained always in the library.
Really, though, this is the story of those two books – “The Lonely Little Star”, which is in a sense the tale of Chise’s life, and that book that Niikura Mayumi gave to Miura-san, “Spring Will be Missed”. Miura, in his final moments as the library begins to disappear around him, gives this book to Chise and implores her to do what he could not – fulfill his promise by returning the book to Niikura-san. This Chise does, first going to the house where the family lives, only to be told that Mayumi-san is in the hospital. She’s an old woman now, with great-grandchildren, but she remembers that book as soon as she sees it.
What stays with me – in addition to the stunning imagery of these episodes – is the pain and loneliness of Chise and the kindness of Miura and Niikura-san. It’s that “simple yet profound” thing the Japanese seem to do so well again. Even as a prisoner, a seeming victim of fate, Miura-san takes it upon himself to give Chise hope – to show her that there is light in the darkness, and that if she looks for it long enough she’ll find it. And so indeed she has, albeit in an extraordinarily unlikely place. I’m ready now for that story to begin, but I’ll enjoy it that much more now, with the richness and poignancy that “Hoshi Matsu Hito” adds to the mix.
Flower
September 13, 2017 at 9:17 pmThank you muchly for your reviews! As breathtaking, moving and lavish as these OVAs were somehow … the last one has not been talked about a lot. Every brick in the house counts! ^^
I thought those moments of encouragement from Miura and normal kindness from Nikura were both beautiful and simple, yet so meaningful and deep – it was very touching to see and I found myself so glad for Chise I misted up while smiling broadly. (As if I were not already invested in her character before these episodes! XD )
Guardian Enzo
September 13, 2017 at 9:26 pmI was close to tears a few times here, actually. Just from the kindness on display and the stark symbolism of the picture book.
Zilla
September 14, 2017 at 5:57 amTo quote Carly Simon (yes, I’m old, get off my lawn) “Don’t mind if I fall apart, there’s more room in a broken heart” This was a really good set of OVAs. As a manga reader I think they definitely add something.
I know it is really unlikely, but if they keep up this production value on the visuals in the upcoming anime, it could possibly push Shouwa Genroku Rakugo Shinjuu Season 2 from my AotY.
Molly
September 14, 2017 at 7:20 amSince it’s a two-cour series, it technically qualifies for 2018.
Guardian Enzo
September 14, 2017 at 8:29 amMy thoughts on that:
Based on the first three episodes, there’s plenty of budget. I doubt they can maintain quite this level for two cours (even in the third OVA ep, there were a few corners cut) but it sure starts out strong.
As for AoTY, as much as I like the manga, it would be hard for me to see Mahoutsukai knocking Rakugo off that perch. (it’d be anime of 2018 for me, anyway). But we’ll see…
elianthos
September 14, 2017 at 2:13 pmIt was a quietly moving and elegant way to tie this tale to the main story. Well done 🙂
Among the lush color palette we were bestowed with this episode delivered some of the best greens. I agree there were some corners being cut but those emerald touches, meh gods. Up there with the best Mushishi scenery.
Crossing fingers and tracing magic circles for the upcoming main series to keep the magic going.