What, you were expecting anything less?
It won’t be appearing in this year’s LiA Top 10 list (thanks to split-cour status) but I can safely say this – Ushio to Tora will certainly be making an appearance in next year’s unless one of two things happen. It’d either have to be the best anime year I can remember (which is pretty damn unlikely) or the third cour would have to see a huge drop-off in quality (which seems only marginally less far-fetched). This series has been damn good for almost its entire first two cours, and that’s no small feat.
I think it’s very illustrative the way Madhouse and its child studio MAPPA have brilliantly handled the two shounen series which have just ended (for now). One Punch Man is a thoroughly modern shounen, ironic and sharply dependent on ant-climax and social commentary. Ushio and Tora could hardly be more traditional – it’s practically proto-shounen, full of boyish martial spirit, GAR and as clear-cut a good vs. evil dynamic as you could ever want. Both are brilliant in their own way, and these studios are too – each is full of very smart and talented people that treated these series in ways that were entirely appropriate to their nature.
If one were to get especially conjectural one might even go far as to to say that OPM and UshiTora provide neat bookends around Madhouse’s shounen masterpiece, Hunter X Hunter. Ushio to Tora clearly influenced it and Wanpanman was clearly influenced by it, and I think Togashi very distinctly provides a bridge between the two works and the eras they represent. That being the case it’s only fitting that the family tree for all three shows is solidly Madhouse.
That brings us to this week’s episode, which brings the first “season” to a close. And it does so in splendid fashion, ably fulfilling the duty of the pivot episode of any split-cour show – it provides a sense of closure while setting the table for what’s to come. One hears many complaints from manga readers about the pacing of this adaptation, never more so than with this arc, but while I’m sure they’re valid I frankly just don’t care. From the perspective of an anime viewer I think the pacing of this series has been exemplary, which is no doubt partly thanks to the fact that mangaka Fujita Kazuhiro was intimately involved in the planning process (which is in turn thanks to the good judgement of MAPPA. If you have a complaint, take it up with him.
Redemption is a pretty big theme of this HAMMR story. Obviously Ushio does’t need to be redeemed, and Tora was already well on his way to his own redemption, but the trio of scientists in charge of this nonsense got off to a pretty awful start last week. And it didn’t help matters that as Ushio and Tora were risking their lives doing battle with the Hakumen avatar, they prepared to turn tail and escape to the surface as poison gas leaked into the facility, leaving not just Ushio and Tora but all their injured colleagues to die.
Helena Markov (Tsuga Yuko) actually gets a pretty decent backstory after all that villainous behavior. Her story of a lost son and the frustration losing him instilled in her as a doctor is a good one, but the most important part of Helena’s experience is the way she frames the main battle in this story for what it is – a struggle for decency and compassion to try and triumph over cruelty and cowardice. The MacGuffin of her observation is the “Metamorphose” effect she describes, the key to harnessing the power to defeat Hakumen no Mono, but that’s symbolic if ever anything was. In truth, Hakumen wins if humans and youkai struggle amongst themselves and with each other, but might just lose if they set aside their differences and if those of great strength are willing to sacrifice themselves for the greater good.
Certainly, “Alpha” Ushio and “Beta” Tora are the key to all this, though I obviously hope they don’t have to sacrifice themselves. Tora’s big moment in this episode comes not during the battle with Hakumen, but afterwards – when Ushio and Asako succumb to the poison gas it would be easy enough to flee on his own from the lab that’s about to be blown up to destroy the regenerating Hakumen, leaving the two of them (and Bal-chan, whom Ushio has managed to cut free) to die along with Helena. But of course that’s not the Tora we’ve come to know, and his status as one of the good guys is as firmly established as it could be by now. He even admits to Baldanders that as humans go, Ushio is “not bad”.
As things draw to a close, we’re left with a last bit of the humor that Ushio to Tora does so well in Ushio’s reaction to Tora’s Asako doll being caught up in the explosion. And a reminder that for all that Ushio is the man on whom the world’s fate probably depends, he’s still a child – and on some level, all he and his friends want to do is live out their childhood days in carefree fashion. That will never happen of course, and if we needed to be reminded we close on Hakumen no Mono’s seething presence waiting at the bottom of the sea to make sure we don’t forget. There’s a lot to look forward to in the final cour next spring, and I fully expect it to deliver the goods with all the brilliance that the first two have and cement Ushio to Tora as one of the best series of the last two years.
sonicsenryaku
December 26, 2015 at 6:14 amdont you just appreciate a season finale that doesnt try to be bombastic but instead, end with a moderately troubling conflict while focusing more on characters? i know i do and this ep of ushitora delivered in that aspect
segafreak2000
December 26, 2015 at 9:45 amOne minor correction there – 'Metamorphose' isn't the name of the effect here, but rather just another word for Youkai that the scientists use (the manga clarifies that, though the anime leaves you to figure that out on your own), while the actual name of the effect is the 'Kirlian level'.
Anyways, as a manga reader… I guess I am satisfied about what they did adapt, and for a streamlined version this one does pretty well. What they did skip was mainly more 'Youkai of the week' stuff (even though some involved parties do return, of course, just as expected for Ushio to Tora) and some more character development for some characters, Asako in particular. It's a shame it happened because those arcs were a lot of fun, but oh well. Definitely looking forward to that third cour to see whether they'll do it justice (and I have no doubt that they will). I'd say it'll definitely stay in your top 10 for the next year all things considered.
Deluxe
December 26, 2015 at 2:03 pmI'm sure MAPPA did their best with the source material they got, but in the end I'll remember Ushio to Tora as a very trite show. It plays every shounen trope possible but never steps from them or tries to subvert them. The fun factor from the beginning got lost midway and replaced by some edgy seriousness mixed with never-ending speeches about power of friendship.
It may be true that Ushio and Tora influenced Togashi (I have no evidence to back up or invalidate that statement) but in this case it's like saying that old robot shows from the 80s influenced Evangelion. That doesn't make them retroactively brillant.
Simone
December 27, 2015 at 2:28 pmIf they hadn't something brilliant enough about them to impress themselves in the mind of the watchers and leave a significant mark in pop culture, no one would have bothered subverting and deconstructing their tropes. They only look trite because they're formulas rehashed for the best part of 30-40 years now. In their time they brought original contributions to the table, like the early Stan Lee & Jack Kirby superhero stories in the west for example.