Another week, another brilliant display of storytelling by Mugen no Juunin: Immortal. Even when it’s immersed in an ongoing plot, as it finally is now, this series has a way of making every episode feel like a self-supporting story in itself. That’s a common trait to good historical drama, I find – it was certainly true with Dororo, for example – and it may be the key to this series’ chances of ultimately succeeding despite having nowhere near enough episodes to properly adapt the manga.
It’s been clear almost from the start that thematically at least, Rin and not Manji was the central character in Immortal. At the very least it’s her arc that defines the story, not his. For now at least this is true in practical terms as well, as circumstances have forced the pair to part ways for now. As a woman she could at least theoretically finagle a way to pass through the checkpoint – as a heavily-scarred outlaw samurai, Manji has no chance whatsoever. While Rin sneaks away in the middle of the night (leaving her bodyguard payment behind) it’s hard to say whether Manji wanted or expected that to happen. I suspect he knew it was the only way and wasn’t going to try and stop her.
The things teenagers will do for revenge – that’s quite the theme in historical anime this year. As it turns out both Manji and Rin’s faces are plastered on wanted posters all over Edo, so Rin has to do her best to lay low and change her appearance; she turns to the kindly cook from last week’s episode for help. She directs Rin to an inn in the small village of Kaminagafusa (fictional as far as I can tell), where the master Nakaya Souhachi (Kirimoto Takuya) and his wife Sato (Atarashi Chieko) apparently have some history as facilitators for smuggling people across the barrier.
We’ve seen a limitless amount of cruelty and depravity in this series already, but the milk of human kindness definitely makes its presence felt this week. It certainly existed even in brutal times like the early Edo Period; the cruelty of the age just makes it stand out all the more. Nakaya and his wife are kind people, and even for the princely sum of 21 Ryo he’s not willing to take her on. It’s not about money, but the consequences of failure which they’ve experienced all too directly. In the end it’s Sato that agrees to smuggle Rin across, extracting the condition that once she makes it she’ll think about pursuing happiness rather than revenge. It sounds so easy, but in practice it’s anything but.
The centerpiece of this episode, to be sure, is the interview with the local commissioner that Nakaya and Rin must endure in order for her to get a pass. It is, in a nutshell, unbelievably tense – because as much as in any swordfight, the consequences here are life and death. Rin’s performance under pressure is pretty astonishing, though all the more so when I thought she was improvising all this on the spot. I’m not sure I believe that a fresh wound would look enough like a two-year old caesarian scar to fool even a man but the story itself was a cracker, and delivered with a spine of steel. As for Sato’s decision to send half the money with Rin on her way, while I suspected it might be coming it was still a rare moment of pure goodness in this bleak setting, and felt totally right.
That was a masterpiece of simplicity, really – doing so much with so little, as this show has already proved itself the master of. It’s going to be interesting to see where things go from here, because while it’s hard to see Manji being sidelined for an extended period, there’s no obvious way for he and Rin to be physically reunited in their current situation. That said, now that she no longer has Manji to depend on but is also free of her guilt about potentially causing him harm , Rin will have the chance to grow as a character in very meaningful ways.
dc22
November 29, 2019 at 6:09 amI’m surprised at how much I’m liking this. There’s nothing that stands out in concept, just pure execution.
Panino Manino
November 29, 2019 at 7:04 am“she turns to the kindly prostitute from last week’s episode for help.”
She wasn’t a prostitute, she was the cook for the inn.
“That was a masterpiece of simplicity, really”
Not that simple, really.
Did you noticed? In the beginning of the episode during the scene when Rin discovers that she is wanted? There we established the “point of view” that would be more openly used latter in the episode. First we see from Rin’s eyes, that people are looking at her, looking and seeing a criminal in her. And then we see most of the interview by the Comissioner’s point of view, with him looking for criminals. This detail contributed a lot for the tension.
This episode surprised my a lot. I was already liking the direction but this one was a highlight.
“It’s been clear almost from the start that thematically at least, Rin and not Manji was the central character in Immortal.”
Now I’m wondering if the series will have the courage to cut Manji and some other character. Simply left out most of “their stories” to keep thing from Rin’s perspective. If they do this time wouldn’t be a problem and would make for a really interesting adaptation.
Guardian Enzo
November 29, 2019 at 9:57 amStructurally though, this is a very simple episode. Two or three extended scenes, very straightforward narrative. Subtle yes, but still simple.
Panino Manino
November 29, 2019 at 10:02 amDamn, I wrote so much that I forget to comment about the most important detail for me.
The anime actually improved the lie scene. In the manga Rin visualizes the lie she is telling. It was a very smart decision to make her remember the night her dojo was attacked in the anime, the “night her fate took a turn”, to make the feelings in her delivery more convincing.
Rin’s lie was so disconcerting for the people there because deep down she wasn’t lying about her pain.
Guardian Enzo
November 29, 2019 at 10:16 amYes, that was tremendous. A classic acting technique – when the moment calls for tears, visually your most painful personal moment. I thought the way Hamasaki brought that off was absolutely brilliant – he showed us what she was doing without beating us over the head with it. I had no idea it was changed from the manga but yes, I think this way is both more powerful and more believable.
Panino Manino
November 29, 2019 at 9:58 am“She wasn’t a prostitute, she was the cook for the inn.”
was I wrong?
Before Rin get to her, the scene just before. It’s her with that man, but why she says “Even if I wasn’t so wounded”? like implying that she was part of the decoy group? Is this another error on Amazon’s subs?