12 comments

  1. P

    I certainly wasn’t expecting something this ecchi to leave me with a big dumb grin on my face every week, lol.

    Suguta Hina and Ishige Shouya were both very good here. I’ve seen people comment on how casting two not-very-established seiyuu (Marin is Suguta’s first leading role, Wakana is Ishige’s third) added to the charm of the lead duo, and I have to agree.

    I think a second season is likely, but I’d hedge my bets on early 2024.

    (Question: On the topic of second seasons, what do you think are the odds of Tower of God getting one?)

  2. Somewhere between slim and none…

    Agreed about the seiyuu. They’re both perfectly fine, and there is added charm in having someone from outside the usual suspects. Anime’s pool of voice talent is much too shallow at the moment – there are plenty of good seiyuu out there but it doesn’t matter if the same half-dozen women and men keep getting all the lead roles.

  3. Hopefully Shinohara returns as director if we do get a second season. The last episode really pulled out all the stops to make sure Bisque Doll ended on a positive note.

    As someone who adores the manga to bits- I’ve enjoyed reading your reviews, Enzo (even when you clearly indicated that you weren’t a fan of a given episode’s content). Thanks.

  4. You’re welcome. I genuinely like this show, even if there are elements of it that don’t click with me. As to Shinohara’s direction that’s a straight-up positive for me – he was already a name to watch but this establishes him.

    As I said, unless it’s a Nozaki-kun scenario that’s totally illogical and inexplicable, a second season is a mortal cinch. Just a question of when.

  5. r

    You’re right. Whatever could have happened with Nozaki-kun? It was such a fantastic comedy and very well regarded. I really didn’t think much about it during these years, but it is really odd no follow-ups ever happened.

  6. \_(ツ)_/

  7. R

    I must say I didn’t particularly fell for Marin during the most part of the show, but after this episode I kind of found her lovely and cute for the first Time, so I’ll be awaiting the series return. Also I loved how Wakana’s world expands that’s awesome.

  8. s

    “I don’t know how Bisque Doll will fare as that sort of series as opposed to the one it was for much of this season – I suspect it would suit my tastes even better, and that a lot of people would disagree”

    I think very little people would disagree. The reasons you had for liking the show despite the aspects that turned you off about it are exactly the very reasons the general public enjoyed the show (this can easily be proven with the general conversation surrounding it). Yea of course, people were also attracted to this series for various reasons whether it was Marin’s stellar character design (her design is the perfect embodiment of character design theory), the passionately and lavishly produced animation, or seeing Marin in a bunch of cute/beautiful/sexy cosplay, but the main draw for many was simply watching two characters who unbashedly enjoyed spending time together doing things with one another; ask most people who watched this show and that’s the answer they’ll give you. It ranked as the top show multiple times because people just felt good watching the two lead characters being endearing and having relatable chemistry in their interactions

  9. I’m unconvinced. I don’t think it would have as much cachet as a conventional romcom as it does as whatever this season was.

  10. s

    Figured you wouldn’t be convinced but the facts (and the people consensus) speak for itself; hell, some of the best selling volumes of this series are the ones that focused more on developing the romance between Marin and Wakana as opposed to anything else so that pretty much nips that conversation in the bud. You’re right that this show wouldn’t have had as much of a grab on the community if it was a conventional romcom, but “conventional” is the operative word here; nothing about the aesthetics of Sono Bisque is conventional (even though the story beats themselves are). It is insanely well-produced with really attractive characters designs and boasts skillful visual direction. If EVERY conventional romcom had at least that to put on the table on the level that Sono Bisque achieves, people would flock to it whether or not there was copious fanservice or “pandering.” But as we know, most anime romcom don’t even possess the level of visual style Sono Bisque has. It goes without saying that people tend to be intrigued by anything that’s visually pleasing and as such, it’s a no-brainer that Sono Bisque would catch people’s eyes. But at the end of the day, people stayed and appreciate the show for its leads romantic chemistry. If more romcoms were this visually exquisite in their production and wholesome as hell on the spectrum, more people will flock to the product: that’s the secret with getting people in the anime community to check something out. Sono Bisque has an alluring sales pitch, but when people actually watch the show and discuss it amongst other people, they’re selling it to others on the merits of the wholesomeness AND production values

    On another note; I thought this finale was a pretty adorable way to end season 1. As I’ve said before, the author of this series understands how to write charming banter between two affection-driven individuals, correctly capturing the rhythm and feeling of two teens growing closer to one another, speaking to each other casually and illustrating their romantic energy through simple, everyday activities without glorifying said activities as some romantic breakthrough. While Marin and Wakana’s relationship or character don’t progress to a level of deepness this season that I think would elevate the storytelling to something great, the show still works without that. I can confidently say the show achieves the horny wholesomeness it aims for and that is a “W” in my books. After this finale, I’m fine with scoring this overall first season a 7/10 and would love to see more from it in the future.

  11. B

    I’m glad you enjoyed this.

  12. M

    I think the best way I could sum up my feelings for S1 is “comfortably stale.” It’s a fine show, but it doesn’t narratively do anything spectacular. I still feel like Marin and Gojo are fairly one-note characters, but they’re not egregious nor are they insufferable, they’re just not all that interesting to me.

    I’m still a little hung up on the whole “unofficial couple” thing only because making them an official and open couple can open the series up to much more interesting possibilities. For the moment, it seems like the series has found its rhythm, its status quo, and it is unlikely to move things too far off said standard. Which, to be fair, is par the course for many long-running manga series.

Leave a Comment