Mugen no Juunin: Immortal continues to be the biggest overperformer of the season, a mid-tier expectations series running with the top dogs. It’s easy to see why this story has proved so appealing for live-action creators, because it lends itself to the sort of naturalistic presentation that Hamasaki-sensei is applying here. Still, there are things that can be done with animation which can’t be replicated with actors and sets, and the veneer of style the director places over the material makes Immortal play almost like an extremely violent impressionist painting.
I don’t know enough about Samura-sensei’s manga to know whether it’s as episodic as this version of the anime has been, or whether Hamasaki is taking this approach as a means of coping with the insane amount of material he has to cover in two cours. But if the latter is the case, the shoe certainly seems to fit – there’s no discordance between the narrative structure and the material. As an “immortal” Manji’s life lends itself to being a series of stories about the encounters he has along the way rather that a traditional protagonist-driven series.
On that note, the river of Manji’s life this week intersects with one who’s followed a similar trajectory for much longer. Shizuka Eiku (Sakuya Shunsuke, yet another wonderful actor contributing to the magic) first appears as a monk, but Manji smells too much blood on him to believe that’s all Shizuka is. He proposes an alliance against Kagehisa, despite the fact that he admires the Itto-ryuu’s practical (and bloody) approach to swordsmanship. It’s Kagehisa’s mortality that’s the problem in Shizuka’s eyes – and it soon becomes clear that mortality is a subject he knows even more about than Manji.
Manji sees no good in this alliance, despite (or perhaps because) of the commonalities he sees between Shizuka and himself. But in their brief skirmish at a roadside inn, Shizuka infects Manji with a poison which kills the sacred bloodworms which heal his wounds. The results are truly horrifying – it’s as if all the wounds the worms have healed begin to reopen at the same time. Surprisingly Rin’s antivenin seems to work (if there’s a backstory behind why it’s sacrificed to the God of pacing) but against his wishes she still rushes out to find a doctor, and finds herself snatched up by Shizuka (exactly what Manji expected).
If I’m honest, I could have done without Rin’s endless crying this episode. It was about the only thing that didn’t work for me, and it’s not as though she’s helpless – she manages to be very useful to Manji here, and it’s not the first time. Not that Shizuka didn’t give her plenty to cry about, even if he did spare the baby. He reveals that he’s been around for over 200 years, “living as a worm” (a more literal self-deprecation for him than it would be for most), and his aim is simply to leave something behind besides the corpses of all the wives, friends and comrades he’s bid farewell to in his long life.
Rin presents Manji with the key question of the episode: between dying without achieving your dream and living forever knowing you’ll never be able to achieve it, which is worse? The answer seems obvious to me, even if Manji is non-committal. What also seems obvious to me is that this ended exactly the way Shizuka wanted it to. He was more than ready to die, and in finding someone in the same boat as he Shizuka found a man worthy of ending his existence. The question now I suppose is, what happens to the baby? I could easily see Rin wanting to keep him, but I can’t even begin to list the reasons why that seems like a very bad idea…
Usa
October 31, 2019 at 10:46 pmRin gets plenty of character development as the series progresses. What I like about her is there’s nuance to her compassionate nature battling with her thirst for vengeance. That’s not something I always see in vengeance-centered narratives.
Anyyyway, this is a much much better episode. Once again Hamasaki’s cinematic expertise is a joy to see. With what I’ve seen so far, gut feel tells me (well.., more so due to previous Hamasaki shows) the 24 episodes might just work for this. The manga did loose steam and focus on certain volumes tbh.
Have you seen Hamasaki’s Shigurui, Enzo? That’s one of the series I thought the adaptation was better than the manga…
Guardian Enzo
October 31, 2019 at 10:54 pmYeah, but it’s been so long I don’t remember it very well. It didn’t strike me as great at the time, just interesting and well-made, but I didn’t have the manga to compare it to.
Having now heard several people note that the manga started to drift after a while, maybe there’s something to the idea that a short adaptation could work OK.
Amarantine
October 31, 2019 at 11:26 pmThe earlier portion of the manga is indeed made up of short stories that do lend themselves to an episodic format. I do feel that some of those stories would be better off as two parters though (like Makie’s), but Eiku’s story here was well suited to a single episode, thankfully.
This episodic nature of the narrative won’t last forever though, so it’ll be interesting to see what Hamasaki does when the story arcs become longer and less self-contained.
Nadavu
November 2, 2019 at 3:32 amSo what was the deal with Eiko offering Rin “immortality”? Was he just teasing her? Or does he go around trying it on as many people that he can, with zero or close-to-zero chances of working?
Guardian Enzo
November 2, 2019 at 7:57 amGood question. I got the idea he was just testing her resolve and messing with her head, but maybe there’s like a 1% chance of it working so why the hell not?
sweejen
November 3, 2019 at 3:31 amI think Eiko was just screwing with her–he likes to inflict pain and harm where he can. He mentioned when Manji burst in that if it were so easy to do, he could have given “immortality” to the people he cared about.