Fall has hardly been a stellar anime season, it’s true. But I think it’s also true that it’s been better than it looked like it was going to be when I wrote the Check-in post in late October. Part of that is the emergence of SSSS.Gridman as a legitimately outstanding series, worthy of potential year-end consideration, and a revelation for Trigger. Part of it is the rehabilitation of Tsurune: Kazemai Koukou Kyuudoubu, that rarest of shows that I dropped from coverage only to pick up again a few weeks later.
Those aren’t the only pleasant surprises of the season, though. There are a couple of other shows I’m still watching and enjoying a lot and while no, I’m not going to start blogging them again (though Tenshura is a two-cour, so I suppose anything’s possible), I did want to comment briefly on them as both are well worth your time.
The first of these is Tensei shitara Slime Datta Ken, and I’m hardly uncovering any secrets with this one – it’s going to be a big hit on disc, and it’s already a massively popular light novel with a manga version now selling nicely too. The most notable thing here, really, is that this is an isekai LN adaptation – and if those aren’t two strikes with me for a series, I don’t know what are. But it’s not only a low bar that makes Tensura look good – it’s actually pretty darn good, period. 8bit has done a really nice job with the production for starters – and it’s worth noting that this is a lesser-known studio that’s quietly compiling a very impressive track record in the last couple of years with the likes of Miira no Kaikata and Shounen Maid.
The common thread between those series and Tensura is heart – all of them are loaded with it. I don’t want to rehash the whole Goblin Slayer ugliness, but it’s impossible not to be struck by the tonal and philosophical contrast between these two shows given the parallels – two massively popular LN adaptations featuring goblins which premiered virtually simultaneously. Tensura is a virtual plea for inter-species brotherhood, with goblins and ogres cast in sympathetic roles. It’s also quite funny (Gobuta is one of the funniest characters of the season), with a sweetheart of a protagonist whose main character traits are empathy and kindness. Frankly, it’s surprising this series is as popular as it is, given its pipeline.
The other series I want to give a bit of praise to is Gaikotsu Shoten’in Honda-san. I might chalk up my appreciation for this half-length show to a “horses for courses” appeal, but it actually seems quite popular too – though nowhere near as much as Tensura. The mangaka behind this series goes only by the nom de plume of “Honda”, and he apparently is indeed a bookseller who publishes a manga about a mangaka who works at a bookstore. No attempt is every made to explain why he’s a skullface – or indeed, why his co-workers are jack-o-lanterns, helmet-heads or paper bag wearers.
See, I worked at bookshops small and large for years – as a bookseller, shipper/receiver, department head, and manager. And it’s striking that the experience seems almost unchanged in Japan – almost every note rings true for me (like the rampant unease of the day the sections get reassigned – I break out in a cold sweat just thinking about it). Bookstores are bookstores, I guess – it transcends time and hemispheres – though of course shops of the type depicted in this series are almost extinct in America, but still omnipresent in Japan (the Japanese love their bookshops, and I love that about them). This show is silly, absurd, and quite irreverent – but also unerringly accurate in the world it depicts (though I’ll have to take its word when it comes to the inside jokes about Japanese publishing houses).
Collectr
December 21, 2018 at 1:56 amSpot on. Tensei is a watchable isekai because it provides a likable hero and a strong supporting cast, with a minimum of the pointless posturing and ludicrous exposition that characterize most of the genre. I only hope that it won’t come down with that most dread of anime comedy diseases, the Serious Development, sometime in the second half.
Honda-kun is non-stop off-the-wall craziness; at times I wish it had a lower gear. I’ll take your word for it that real bookshops are like that, though, because they’re an endangered species in the US, outside of big cities and college towns.
Haak
December 21, 2018 at 5:19 amIt’s funny that you note the differences in tone between Tensei Slime and Goblin Slayer because it wasn’t lost on the author of Goblin Slayer either:
https://forums.animesuki.com/showpost.php?p=6283935&postcount=143
And to be honest with you, I kinda lean on Goblin Slayer authors side on this one. Now I’m not the best authority because I’ve only seen manga adaptations of these Isekai/Tensei novels but I have (sped)read a lot of them and the one thing a lot of them have in common is that they’re lighthearted to the point where I feel like it’s a cover to hide the painful lack of ambition. They’re almost always boilerplate super-safe stories where hardly anything bad happens and nobody is ever really thrown outside their comfort zone and if they are then not for very long. And again, I’m not watching Tensei Slime so I could be wrong about it but I did read a few chapters and it struck me as more of the same. But for the record, it’s not just limited to the Isekai/Tensei genre either. I see this time and time again in CGDCT shows that try to have some kind of cool shtick to them. The best example I can thing of Bodacious Space Pirates: 26 episodes of “fun and games” and no actual pirating (I pirate more than they do).
Don’t get me wrong though: Goblin Slayer is undoubtedly an absolute piece of turd. It’s all the way on the other end of the scale of darkness and edginess in the crudest, most contrived ways just for the sake of it and it all falls apart because it’s still based on the type of “RPG game logic” that Isekai/Tensei stories have as well (which is easier to portray lighthearted and clearly the only way it should be portrayed).
Kinai
December 23, 2018 at 7:42 pm@Haak:
I dont think that Goblin Slayer is an “absolute piece of turd”. It is very interesting in some ways, and there is a lot more to go in the scale of darkness and edginess. It is almost lighthearted compared with Berserk.
On the other hand, what is the minute where the author talks about the differences between Slime and GS?