It’s probably in bad taste to compare military dramas to sports series, but in a way, the two genres are kind of similar. You have your setup episodes, where you meet the cast and get to know them. You have the night before the big game episode, where everyone reflects on the battle to come. And generally an aftermath, as the tears flow and the survivors (just play along for argument’s sake) reflect on their victory – or defeat.
The tentpoles of sports anime of course – what all that other material is stretched around – are the game episodes themselves. And that’s definitely what we had this week on Angolmois, where the siege of Kanatanoki begins in earnest. What we know and the defenders don’t, of course, is that Shiraishi has betrayed the defenders. Nagamine suspects but doesn’t act; Jinzaburou should suspect but seems not to. If this super-warrior has a blind spot, it appears to be personal loyalty – it’s what got him banished in the first place. But ironically that same loyalty that ended his life as a landed samurai now threatens to end his life altogether due to being misplaced.
My sense of what happens with Shiraishi’s betrayal on the West Wall – why it doesn’t result in unmitigated disaster – is not that Nagamine or Kuchii had predicted it, but that they were being exceptionally careful. To what extent that came from suspicion and what from simple acknowledgement of their desperate situation I’m not sure, but their fire traps were certainly a sensible measure in hindsight. Burning your land behind you is not a decision that could have been taken lightly for a people who live as the Toibarai do, but it’s better than being wiped out.
The question of time is an interesting one as it plays out in all this. In one sense it’s Kuchii’s greatest enemy, since he desperately needs his reinforcements, and holding out till they arrive is his safest strategy. But it’s also true that time is Jinzaburou’s friend, because the Mongols don’t really need to win this battle – and their generals know it. Kyushuu is the real prize and always has been – remaining on Tsushima to battle its defenders is a matter of plunder and pride, but there are limits to both of those motivating factors. It’s a delicate equation – the harder this is the more incentive there is for the Mongols to give up before they lose too much time and/or manpower. But the more they’re humiliated by Kuchii and his guerrilla band, the more their pride demands a pound of flesh as revenge.
The other factor playing out in the defender’s favor is the diversity of the Mongol forces – which is historically accurate. This is not one unified invasion force – it’s multiple armies of multiple ethnicities and languages, to some extent in fierce competition with each other. I think this really comes into play in the siege of Kanatanoki, as poor decisions are made on the basis of haste or a desire to stand out.
Ultimately, though, Kuchii probably has a stronger ally in psychology than anything else. The more he can convince the Mongols that he’s crazy, indefatigable or both, the less appetite for this war of attrition they’re going to have. And after his attempted sabotage of the West Wall mostly fails, Shiraishi – as always too clever by half – realizes that bringing Jinzaburou’s head back is probably the best way to restore his standing with the Mongols. The irony here is strong – Shiraishi has become the very thing he detested so much in Obusama, and he’s smart enough to realize the full depth of his crimes. But he’s pot committed now, and given that Kuchii wears an armor that’s stronger than Mithril with three episodes left, if I were Shiraishi I would avoid buying any green bananas.
elianthos80
September 6, 2018 at 1:08 pm“given that Kuchii wears an armor that’s stronger than Mithril with three episodes left, if I were Shiraishi I would avoid buying any green bananas.” * triggered by the mentions of bananas *
more seriously don’t jinx the the literal and figurative plot armour with the mithril comparison please :,)
P.S.: I am in deep Tsushima Cats spotting withdrawal. Sana aka Citadel Girl’s Kitty you’re my only hope :,(
Guardian Enzo
September 6, 2018 at 2:23 pmSana is probably off somewhere with Amushi making sure they don’t die without having certain experiences first.
elianthos80
September 6, 2018 at 2:39 pm* gasps * * eyes blog post tentpole episode analogy again * * eyes blogger *
The wild guesser
September 6, 2018 at 6:59 pmSo, when it comes to formative events in the national history of Japan, where does the Mongol invasions rank? Around the significance of the Tokugawa Shogunate or Meiji Restoration? A little more? Or less?
Guardian Enzo
September 6, 2018 at 7:45 pmHonestly, I don’t feel qualified to answer that, but it strikes me that the Tokugawa shogunate and Meiji restoration have an immediacy in modern Japanese life that the Mongol invasions don’t. Those who study history certainly realize what a near miss that was, how it would have changed history itself had it turned out differently. But at the visceral level I think it ranks a level below (one reason why it hasn’t been a more common topic for manga).
I would also put the Genpei War in that top tier, FWIW.
The wild guesser
September 6, 2018 at 8:29 pmInteresting,
I’ve seen a lot of media coverage of the Sengoku Jidai (manga, novels, movies), but I haven’t seen the Genpei War get nearly as much coverage, I wonder why that is.
Guardian Enzo
September 6, 2018 at 8:59 pmThat is indeed a fascinating question. Maybe because it goes much farther back. But I also get the sense that it’s almost a sacred thing, and that the Tale of the Heike is so revered that it scares others off tackling it.
The more one looks at that event, the more it seems as if it would be packed with absolutely fascinating potential stories for manga or anime to tackle. I would love to see something about the Taira in hiding in the time after their defeat, for example.
Shinrakugin
September 9, 2018 at 7:10 amI get the impression Jinzaburou’s kinda enjoying himself in all of this. Like, sure, he’s worried – his neck on the line as well – but he seems much more comfortable with the war than everyone else. Seeing him fight is kinda like seeing a tiger hunt: you get the impression they’re in their natural depth. He seems like the kind of character that would love being part of Kingdom’s cast. I see him as being midway between Shin and Kanki. He’s not nearly as cruel as the latter, but I also wouldn’t say he’s as scrupulous as the former. Making this kind of comparison, I wonder what he would be like if he had some sort of Renpa to his Ouki…