Sometimes a lack of surprises can be a good thing.
I can say this about Mahoutsukai no Yome so far – it’s delivering on every level. I was expecting it to be a leading contender for the best series of the fall, and it’s pacing the field right now. I was expecting Wit to deliver gorgeous backgrounds and fluid animation, and they’ve done it. And every episode has been a near letter-faithful adaptation of the corresponding manga chapters, with only very minor changes made for the sake of narrative fluidity. If anything the anime is an even more engrossing experience than the manga, but with this studio and staff on-board that’s no surprise either.
While I have a few niggles with the writing of the manga, on balance I think The Ancient Magus’ Bride is an excellent series that has an undeniable quality of “specialness” to it. And one of my favorite aspects of Yamazaki-sensei’s work here is that she takes her time setting things up – characters arcs progress at a natural pace, and events never seem to be rushed to a conclusion. That’s especially welcome in the era of the light novel, when even many manga rush through development in order to appeal to an audience bereft of attention spans. I have heard complaints that Chise is too passive, too helpless – but given her background, how could anyone expect this girl to overcome her issues and change overnight?
This part of the story is largely concerned with Chise’s education, largely an experiential one. But Elias is teaching her along with life, albeit slowly – at this point she’s helping out in the apothecary side of the business, but her sense of proportion could still use a little work. Her first prescriptions run a little potent (a potion to prevent nightmares turns into a sleeping potion), but before she has a chance to fine tune her skills Elias takes her out on another job – the third and theoretically final one he has to do for the Church.
Why does Elias have to do these jobs? “A long time ago, I made a mistake” he tells Chise cryptically. It’s hard to imagine anyone forcing Elias to do something he truly doesn’t wish to do, but we don’t know what consequences there might be for his refusal. This particular assignment is to investigate a black dog that’s been seen around a village church – a possible “church grim”. This – like almost every legend in Mahoutsukai – is a part of real-world folklore, again from the British Isles and Scandinavia. The church grim does not always have to be a black dog (the reason why it often is one is grim, indeed) but that’s the most common form the apparition takes.
By the time Elias and Chise arrive, a crowd has gathered around a mutilated dead body, horribly scratched and bitten. There’s company here, too – Alice is on-hand. And when Chise wanders into the graveyard to investigate, she sees malevolent spirits gathered by many gravestones – and an especially terrifying one accosts her. She’s saved by a young man named Ulysse (Uchiyama Kouki), who notes that she reminds him of his sister Isabelle before morphing into a black dog, then passing out from what appear to be grave wounds.
The other part of this story is Joseph (Murase Ayumu) who’s blackmailed Renfred (whose arm he’s taken) and Alice into providing him materials – materials he needs to produce chimera (Joseph is not doing the reputation of sorcerers any good). Alice describes him as a kid – which is how we’ve seen him of course – but says that his form appears to be strangely “overlapping”. Alice sees the dog as potential material to offer up to Joseph, but Chise won’t have that – and she (rather proactively) uses her accidental sleeping potion to help Alice take an unplanned nap.
Give Joseph credit – he’s managed to do something no one else has been able to so far, and that’s push Elias into showing his true form. It’s probably just as well Chise was unconscious when that happened (though not that the reason was that she’d just been impaled by a giant thorny tentacle), because it certainly would have been traumatic seeing him that way. The only conscious being who doesn’t seem horrified is Joseph – whose visage is as infuriatingly scornful and mocking as ever. What happens when a sorcerer and a mage stare each other down with hostile intent? In a series that’s overfond of cliffhangers, we’ll have to wait until next week to find out.
Dein
November 19, 2017 at 6:08 amLast weeks episode left a rather uneven impression on me, but I thought I’d give it another week to see how things develop. Initally, I thought it was the off-pace comedy that was annoying me (kudos to them for skipping it this week), but it actually seems more fundamental than that. This show feels incredibly hollow to me and I feel myself outside the fantasy bubble looking in.
Almost all individual parts are great by themselves, but they don’t merge together in any sort of interesting way. The two main characters have interesting concepts but are very wooden and their interactions with each other put them well below the rest of the cast for me. There are weird minor things like Elias conjuring up a disguise to go out in public one moment and then just rolling onto the crime scene in his real form the next. It leaves you with plenty of questions but makes no effort to try and answer them, instead only dropping vague hints, if you can even call them that. Chise gets repeatedly put into “mortal peril” that even the show itself doesn’t treat seriously so it’s hard to really get emotionally invested in those moments. The OVA left such a wonderful impression on me and the main series so far has kinda paled in comparison.
Overall, it’s a weird ride. The general consensus is that this show is excellent and it makes me wonder if this is one of those cases where familiarity with the source material gives it an entirely different perspective.
Guardian Enzo
November 19, 2017 at 7:58 amTough to say. How do you feel about the manga itself? Do you have any of the same issues?
Dein
November 19, 2017 at 11:13 amI haven’t read it. That’s why I’m wondering if the show is better suited for for people who have. I’m not a big manga reader, but I’ll probably give it a go, because it really is one of those cases where I want to love the show, but it’s not quite connecting.
Kurik
November 20, 2017 at 5:26 pmI wondered about the conjuring disguise as well and it did pull me out and had me questioning what was going on. My brain quickly suggested that Chise sees him as he truly is and while he is among humans they see what he want’s them to see. If that is the case they should explain that. I am in agreement with the ‘what danger will Chise get into this week’ aspect of the show as pretty much every episode she is in mortal danger with or without Elias present. However I am still enjoying the show, not as much as I enjoyed the OVA but enjoying it nonetheless as its quite unique and it is taking its time which i don’t mind.
UndeadCalamari
November 19, 2017 at 2:04 pmThis week’s episode really brought me back into the show. The last 2-3 weeks haven’t been bad, but just didn’t do it for me as much as the OVA or the first couple of episodes had. But wow this one was great.
I haven’t read the manga and probably won’t, but I don’t think it’s needed to enjoy the show. It probably helps seeing it brought to life, but I’m still trying the show while being completely in the dark with it. I do think that it’s a a bit of a slow burn once you past the art, animation, and sense of magical awe. The characters aren’t what would typically hook everyone imo. A fundamentally broken girl and an inhuman “something” that we don’t really know anything about. I can see why some people would find difficulty in caring about them and their interactions.
Guardian Enzo
November 19, 2017 at 2:14 pmZombie Squid, I don’t fundamentally disagree with any of that. But I kind of like stories about broken people trying to heal, and Elias to me is a fascinating enigma and not just an enigma. The teasing glimpses we get of what’s going on inside there are enough to keep me engaged with his arc.