First Impressions – Another

Another - 01 - Large 09 Another - 01 - Large 16 Another - 01 - Large Preview 03

It’s very hard for a show with the kind of expectations I had for Another to live up to them, and after watching the premiere I have to say it didn’t. It surpassed them.

OP: “Kyoumu Densen” (凶夢伝染; Nightmare Contagion) by ALI PROJECT

Another - OP - Large 01 Another - OP - Large 02 Another - OP - Large 03
Another - OP - Large 04 Another - OP - Large 05 Another - OP - Large 06

Simply put, this was an outstanding effort all-around. It’s PA Works, so you know it’s going to look great, and you won’t be disappointed. Character designs and backgrounds are gorgeous, animation is fluid and natural, and the overall look of the series is hauntingly beautiful. That’s not an accidental choice of words here, as PA combines their usual mastery of color with some interesting muted schemes and use of shadows to help create the pervasive tone of dread that pervades the entire episode. Director Mizushima Tsutomu has put the nightmare of Blood-C behind him, and appears to be back to his usual stellar form.

People are calling this a horror series, but I suspected it would be more mystery/suspense than horror, and that’s the vibe I got from the first episode. From the minute ninth-grader Sakakibara Kouichi (Abe Atsushi) moves to his late mother’s home town, it’s obvious that something is terribly wrong. He’s laid up in the hospital with a collapsed lung, for starters, where he’s visited by three classmates – Akazawa Izumi (Yonezawa Madoka), Kazami Tomohiko (Ichiki Mitsuhiro) and Sakuragi Yukari (Nonoka Ai). They’re quite a glum trio, and seem very interested in whether Kouichi-kun has ever lived in Yomiyama before (he swears he hasn’t). When he meets a fourth Yami North student, a pale girl with an eyepatch who introduces herself as Misaki Mei (Natsumi Takamori) in the hospital elevator, things get even weirder. Mei takes the elevator to the sub-basement (where the morgue is) and says she has to make a delivery to her “poor other half”.

The sense of wrongness here is certainly not subtle, nor is it trying to be – it permeates every frame of the ep, and writer Ayatsuji Yukito – a legendary “neo-orthodox” horror novelist and husband of fellow legend Ono Fuyumi – isn’t trying to disguise that something terrible happened here. The intro tells us that a pretty and popular girl named Misaki died 26 years ago, and the story is set in 1998. Kouichi is told that his name is “linked with death” by Mei when he meets her again on the roof on his first day at school – during which meeting she also informs him that his Class 3-3 is “close to death” and warns him not to try and get close to her. Sickness and ill fortune seem to follow the class – a fellow student has a heart condition, Sakuragi has a bandaged ankle and Akazawa is out sick. While just what’s happened isn’t clear, it’s obvious that the Kouichi is caught up in something he doesn’t understand at all, and it’s something nasty.

I love all the odd little touches that contribute to the disquiet we feel. The crows who appear on the roof behind Mei. The fact that Kouichi’s grandmother and grandfather are heard but their faces never seen (significant?). The sound design helps too, mostly chilling silence with occasional snippets of spare and austere BGM, and strange and jarring bouts of static. Mizushima-sensei gives us quick cuts to dolls in various states of distress (Mei is carrying such a doll when Kouichi meets her in the elevator). The only series I can compare this to in term of feel is Ghost Hound, because of the beautiful visuals and stunning sound but also because rather than gore and violence, both shows mostly rely on keeping the audience unsettled and unsure. This is horror, of a sort, but true psychological horror.

I’m not ready to guess what the true situation here is yet, but I’m on pins and needles to find out. Kouichi can clearly see Mei, who seems very obviously to be dead – but can no one else see her, or are they merely pretending not to? The timing of events is interesting – I’d thought Kouichi’s Mom or Dad might have been involved in the 1985 incident with Mei, but the timing really doesn’t fit. I assume the Grandparents are her parents, as she was obviously born and raised in Yomiyama, and the father is absent, travelling in India as part of his job as a college professor. We know that Kouichi’s Mom has died in circumstances dire enough to make her father tremble and cry when he talks about “that” happening to her – but no details yet. It seems as if things took a supernatural turn when another student referred to Mei being “still here” – and hereafter the school acted as if she weren’t dead, leaving her desk untouched and even making a place for her at graduation. But did the comment spur the haunting, or was it in response to it?

I haven’t been this excited about a premiere for a while – Another looks as if it has the chance to be really, really good. PA Works does have a history of starting out gangbusters and having trouble finishing a series, but the fact that this is based on a highly acclaimed novel should give us some protection against a significant drop in quality. It was obvious from the staff involved that the potential for greatness was here, and it appears that the story is up to the challenge. The cast isn’t full of huge names, but they’re pretty much spot-on across the board – subdued and pensive performances that match the story and visuals. In short, there’s no reason whatsoever why this shouldn’t be one of the best series of 2012. That doesn’t mean it will be, but at this point I wouldn’t bet against it.

Another - 01 - Large 14 Another - 01 - Large 15 Another - 01 - Large 17
Another - 01 - Large 18 Another - 01 - Large 20 Another - 01 - Large 21
Another - 01 - Large 22 Another - 01 - Large 23 Another - 01 - Large 26
Another - 01 - Large 28 Another - 01 - Large 29 Another - 01 - Large 31
Another - 01 - Large 32 Another - 01 - Large 34 Another - 01 - Large 35

ED: “anamnesis” by Annabel

Another - ED - Large 01 Another - ED - Large 02 Another - ED - Large 03


  1. d

    Is she a ghost? I don't think so. Think she just shares the same name (@Enzo: The original girl is Misaki, not Misaki Mei). And it being outcasted. But that would be too simple a plot .Reminds me of Higurashi, rural town with a hidden past. Just that Higurashi is scary cause of the insanity is laid bare. This one is scary due to not knowing what the insanity is.
    I have high expectations.

    P.S. Did that girl really fall sick? Or is it an excuse for something else? Class bullying those who do not follow the "Group mentality" said by the aunt? Maybe that is why the girl "fell" down.
    Or perhaps Class 3 is for all the misfits. -unlikely

  2. K

    Having read the manga I am concerned how it will be adapted as an anime. The manga is really slow moving (sadly) and takes quite a while before it gets going good (very similar to Shiki).

    I just hope folks hang with it until the story gets fleshed out and don't abandon it before it gets going good.

  3. d

    @Karma: it is alreadys good to me. probably would hold me for 2 more ep

  4. I agree, there's no "get going" for me. It's already going. The fact that this is a 12-ep series also means the adaptation will likely be on the brisk side.

  5. w

    Had pretty much the exact opposite reaction to this episode.

    I understand that Another was going for the slow burn, but to me the whole episode just felt really forced and not particularly scary at all. Everything, from the crows to the odd camera angles to the color scheme to the dilating pupils, was screaming so loudly that it wanted to be unnerving that it completely failed at doing so. The fact that none of the characters are particularly interesting really didn't help matters.

    Watched it a second time to see if I hadn't given it a chance, and to be fair I did like it a bit more that second time. Could also be that it's headed towards amazing places, as well. It's great that the people behind Another are trying to make something different from the stereotypes that have governed this season, and normally I'd be behind them every step of the way. Another has a lot of the pieces of a good horror anime; I just wish that the execution was up to par.

  6. a

    Agreed. I stopped watching after the first ep, because, while they had the visual techniques down, they failed to pull off the effect they were obviously going for. I mean, what's the deal with a working hospital with DARK hallways and rooms??? Bad enough that X-Files introduced the FBI office with no ceiling lights! 😀

    Anyway, good to hear viewers enjoying it. The visuals were definitely great and the review's kept me from writing off the series!

  7. K

    Another is not so much a "horror" anime as its a mystery/psychological one. The horror part is subtle or slow moving. From the comments here and at RC I think folks have the impression that monsters or ghosts will be jumping out and scaring or killing people. Its not gonna be like that. Or at least not for quite a while I think.

  8. S

    Glad to see Mizushima sensei moving on from the Blood-C train wreck. This is looking really good and I can't wait to see more. I would have preferred the more mature-looking character designs from the source but in an odd way, the moe-fied version actually work quite well to bring out a very different eerie feeling.

  9. t

    I really don't know if this is the result of Mizushima learning from the blood-c experience or him not having clamp on his back,or maybe a bit of both

  10. K

    Has anyone read anything about fallout from how Blood-C was reviewed by fans? It turned out so awful I can't believe the anime makers and Clamp didn't acknowledge that they screwed up so badly. I was so disapointed. I wanted it to be good and it had its moments but they were far and few between.

  11. S

    you better freaking blog this Enzo!
    It's going to be a thrilling ride, by the looks of it. An anime has never tried to scare me before. I like it.

  12. b

    I'm torn into going to this show.

    On one hand this is PA Works and they havent exactly impressed me since True Tears. Canaan was meh, Angel Beats was a disappointment and Hanasaku could have gone the distance but didnt.
    Mizushima is good at comedy and that's why Blood-C was hilariously bad.
    And the hype before the season means expectations and disappointments later on. Also, Ali Project.

    On the other hand, the first episode was interesting. The sound director has good shows in his belt and delivered some nice music here. And it has what PA Works excels at:beautiful and realistic backgrounds.
    So yeah.

  13. Totoum, I think Clamp totally screwed him. Mizushima wasn't the problem.

  14. A

    I kind of thought Ghost Hound would be brought up. I liked Another enough, but it had none of the subtleties and nuance that auteur director Nakamura brought to the former.

    I'll check out the manga though, to see if the execution is better.

Leave a Comment